Author
|
Topic: BLuegrass Dobro anyone??
|
Dennis Wood Member From: Savannah, TN USA
|
posted 05 August 2002 02:09 PM
profile edit
I am picking around the idea of learning bluegrass dobro(i play steel now).what is the brand of choice amongst bluegrass pickers? Does anyone have a dobro for sale or trade? My son and tele picker is learning bluegrass banjo and i don't want to be left out I have never really cared for bluegrass but it seems to be gaining quite a following since the movie and soundtrack "O brother where art thou".------------------ Sierra U-12 Crown Gearless, Peavey Nashville 400, Peavey TransTube Fx, Peavey Stereo 212, Peavey TT Bandit w/ex speaker. Tele, Strat, 1970 Les Paul Std. Harley-Davidson Heritage Softail Classic......
|
Ron Randall Member From: Dallas, Texas, USA
|
posted 05 August 2002 06:46 PM
profile send email edit
The Dobro brand, the new ones are made by Gibson, is a very good instrument. The pre Gibson models are great, too. Squareneck instruments are preferred. Beard, and Scheerhorn resonators are all the rage right now. (get in line, then get a loan. they go as high as $4,000 since the popularity of O Brother and Mr. Jerry Douglas.) Douglas uses plenty of Dobro brand instruments on tour. I play a Benoit, made here in Texas. Carrol Benoit makes 6 and 8 string resonators. I think they are the best. IMHO. www.benoitguitars.com I have a custom walnut Dobro with very ornate inlaid fretboard. It is about 20 years old. I would consider selling it for $2,500. Good luck. It is a zoo out there. Check eBay ------------------ Fender Stringmaster T-8 Fender Strat 8 string Benoit |
D Schubert Member From: Columbia, MO, USA
|
posted 05 August 2002 07:40 PM
profile send email edit
Don't rule out a vintage guitar. Unlike pre-war Martin guitars and old Gibson mandolins, the prices on pre-war wood-bodied Dobros & Regals have not gone completely out of sight. If you have a chance, check out the inventory of old Dobros at George Gruhn's in Nashville -- www.gruhn.com, I think -- to get an idea of market prices. You may find an old Model 27 or something like it -- mahogany body, spider bridge, two screen holes, three small holes at the end of the fingerboard, square neck, solid peghead -- in the $1500 to $2000 range -- that will be a "pro" instrument that can go toe-to-toe with the dreaded b***o. If you're going to play bluegrass, pick hard, string it up with very heavy strings --I like the Beard Special 29's -- and get a Scheerhorn or Tipton bar that's anatomically correct for slants, hammer-ons and pull-offs. A good set-up -- cone, bridge, nut, etc. -- is important to ensure the best tone & volume. To my hillbilly ears, the old resonators usually sound better than the ones just picked off the vine (flame suit on!). And they're easier to re-sell if you find that you aren't cut out to be a bluegrass man. [This message was edited by D Schubert on 05 August 2002 at 07:41 PM.] |
Pete Grant Member From: Auburn, CA, USA
|
posted 05 August 2002 11:12 PM
profile send email edit
I love my National Model D squareneck. It lists for about $1800 and kicks ass. http://www.nationalguitars.com/modeld.html |
HowardR Member From: N.Y.C.,N.Y.
|
posted 06 August 2002 06:57 AM
profile send email edit
Dennis, I have a 1973 OMI Dobro. I am the original owner. I bought it brand new in that year and it came with a round neck. A few years later, I had OMI put a square neck on it. I have the original round neck. I also have insructional material, a capo and a couple of Stevens bars. Even have the original shipping carton with the OMI logo. This is an "everything you need" package. If bluegrass turns out to be "not your thing", put the round neck back on. Click on my email above if this interests you and I'll send photos and price. |
Ron Randall Member From: Dallas, Texas, USA
|
posted 12 August 2002 04:23 PM
profile send email edit
I see a couple of Tut Taylor models made by Crafters of Tennesse on eBay. The buy it now price is 1,000. This is a very low price. Ends soon. I saw a pre Gibson squareneck, all maple, with gold plated covers, original case, and the original gold plated strings. Circa 1980. I played and looked it over good. $1,200 plus tax at a guitar shop in Dallas. I was tempted to buy it, but I have too many now. Email if interested. ------------------ Fender Stringmaster T-8 Fender Strat 8 string Benoit |
Andy Zynda Member From: Wisconsin
|
posted 12 August 2002 05:56 PM
profile send email edit
I'm probably gonna get blasted for this, but I tried a (new) Gibson, Regal, Dean, and a metal Tricone Johnson. None of them seemed to sing much. Sorta flat sounding. Then I tried a low cost, Johnson squareneck. (around $350) and it sounded great! Sweet, balanced and rings like a bell.Sue me, but it sounds great. -andy- |
Dennis Wood Member From: Savannah, TN USA
|
posted 13 August 2002 06:04 AM
profile edit
THanks for the info guys. The $300-400 range is more to my liking as i am just starting out on the bluegrass thing. Musicians Friend has a square neck Regal i think for around $350 new. any feedback on this guitar? thanks in advance.. dennis |
Howard Parker Member From: Clarksburg,MD USA
|
posted 13 August 2002 06:17 AM
profile send email edit
Extracted from the iBluegrass WebzineGetting Started - Instruments Under $1,000 - Instruments Under $1,000 OK, you've decided to take the plunge and make the transition from fan to player. Now what? Choosing an instrument has got to be pretty high on the agenda and you'd like to do it without breaking the bank. Where to look and what can you expect? Good news. For less than $1,000 you'll be able to find a perfectly serviceable resonator guitar, either new or used, that will last you for years, perhaps for the rest of your playing career. For the sake of this discussion I'll keep the price below $1,000. If this is a bit over your budget, never fear. Some of your choices will be well under this mark, even under $500. Howard's rule No. 1: Never buy an instrument without you (or a knowledgeable friend) inspecting and/or playing the instrument first. Please try enlisting the aid of a local player in your search. Contact me if you'd like some names. OK....What are the choices in this price range? If we are talking new we've narrowed the choices down to imported guitars (with one notable exception). Some of the names you'll see; Regal, Johnson, Flinthill, Fender and others. Most of these guitars are available in the $300-$600 range (all priced are approximate retail). My observation is that every one of these guitars that I have ever played were in serious need of a setup by a qualified luthier. This alone should not deter you from choosing one of the imports. It just means you should budget an addition $75-150 for an additional makeover by your friendly resonator repair guy. For $150 the luthier will set up the guitar properly and replace the resonator and spider with standard U.S. made components. This will make an incredible difference in the instruments' sound. For $75 or so the nut and saddle will be replaced and the strings properly spaced. This will make the guitar much more playable. The exception to all of this is the incredible and unusual Melobro made by Ted Smith. Unusual because the instrument body is fiberglass and not wood. The components are all standard, U.S. made, high quality parts. The instrument had been retailing for $900 or so which makes it an incredible value. They also sound great and should be considered on the high end of our price range. They do look a bit odd, ie., non-traditional. Used DobroTM are also available for less than $1,000. The DobroTM is several cuts above the import. Instruments of the O.M.I (pre Gibson) era are available in the $750-$1,000 range. In my opinion these instruments vary all over the place in terms of sound, playability and construction quality. Remember rule #1? Do not buy sight unseen. DobroTM shipped many of these instruments with soft wood saddle inserts and plastic nuts. You can upgrade these instruments for about $50 and come away with the guitar sounding just fine. Lest I forget. You can find contact info for many reso luthiers on the RESOGUIT website , http://www.resoguit.com , or email me privately at . and I'll see what I can do to help. [This message was edited by Howard Parker on 13 August 2002 at 06:18 AM.] [This message was edited by Howard Parker on 13 August 2002 at 06:20 AM.]
|
Dan Farrell Member From: Anaheim, Ca, USA
|
posted 13 August 2002 10:26 AM
profile send email edit
Dennis--- like you, I've been playing pedal steel and wanted to try Dobro. I got one of the Regals (an RD-45) and am very happy with it. Sure couldn't beat the price. I am a newbie but it sure plays nice and sounds good.Dan Farrell Anaheim CA '97 Carter D-10 Nashville 1000 Regal RD-45 |
HowardR Member From: N.Y.C.,N.Y.
|
posted 13 August 2002 01:38 PM
profile send email edit
Howard's Rule #2.....see Howard's Rule #1  |
Stephen Gambrell Member From: Ware Shoals, South Carolina, USA
|
posted 13 August 2002 03:15 PM
profile send email edit
Dennis, read Howard's rule again. And again! The Regal, Johnston, and a couple of others are all Korean made instruments. Not bad in and of itself, but eventually you'll want tone! The OMI, and(as far as I'm concerned)Gibson Dobros, can't be counted on, either. So, get a Regal. Practice up on it, but when you get in a jam session, you won't be heard. The Crafter's are good instruments, but if you want to stay with Reso, get in touch with Ivan Guernsey or one of the other custom builders. Enjoy yourself, and God bless! |
Aaron Balano Member From: San Rafael, Ca
|
posted 14 August 2002 12:18 PM
profile send email edit
I think your choices depend on how serious you are about playing the thing. If you intend to spend alot of time with it, do not buy a cheap one. You will quickly want something better and they do not retain their value upon resale. If you want something to just mess around with and do not see yourself getting serious with the instrument, do NOT, under any circumstances play anything expensive! The difference will be very noticeable and you will then feel that the cheaper instruments are no good. As with most guitars, make sure you play alot of them (or even just strum them) before you buy one. There is a huge difference in sound from guitar to guitar even among the same brand and model. Make sense? |
R. L. Jones Member From: Lake Charles, Louisiana, USA
|
posted 21 August 2002 08:03 PM
profile send email edit
I`ve heard many different brand name guitars and played some of them , found some real good sounds over the years. There`s something in these exotic wood guitars ,handcrafted ,by Mr. Carrol Benoit, that is outstanding. They have volume, tone, beauty. They are in a class by themselves. jonesgtrmn |
mikey Member From: Hawaii, Big Island
|
posted 25 August 2002 02:33 PM
profile send email edit
If you are just learning, I would personally recommend a Flinthill from Beard Guitars/Resophonic Outfitters highly, they are a tremendous value(@$600 new) and sound great...I bought one a few years ago, to back up my 30's Dobro,and so I'd not have to retune or change strings,(going from G to C6) and I liked the tone so much, I ended up playing it more than my Dobro and bought another one, so now I have one for C6 and one for G, and at $600 I don't have to worry about sand or people borrowing it or leaving it in the trunk,putting it in the baggage compartment on a plane or whatever...the only change I make is replacing the cone COVERPLATE, as the Flinthills are professionally set up in the USA from Regals made in Korea and the coverplate is just Nickle plated (I believe) and from resting my hand,(for me anyway) really eats up the plating, so I put real nice Old heavy Chrome Dobro cover plates on and they just wipe clean real easy after playing...the original covers needed to be polished and scrubbed to get the tarnish and smudges off after even just a little playing..but that's a MINOR complaint...they do sound VERY good, record well and are an excellent value. Mike | |