Author
|
Topic: 8-String Triple Necks
|
Lee Baucum Member From: McAllen (Extreme South) TX - The Final Frontier
|
posted 21 June 2006 11:59 AM
profile send email edit
I've been playing pedal steel for many years now and am just now trying to get the hang of playing 8-string non-pedal steel.It seems that quite a few triple necks are tuned to E13, A6, and C6. To further complicate things, I see that the C6 tuning might have a high G (5th) on top or it might have an E (3rd) on top. It looks like the A6 tuning usually has an E (5th) on top. Then there are various E tunings, some with a high G# (3rd) on top and some with an E on top. Usually there will be a C# and a D in there somewhere, making it an E13. Let's say you have a triple neck and need to learn a new song. What is the deciding factor on which tuning to use? Or, do you keep all the necks hot and jump from neck to neck, depending on the chord needed at the time? I just have a single-8 and am trying to figure out if there is a pattern of thought, when choosing a tuning. I started out with a C6, E on top and F on the bottom. I like those big, fat Maj7 chords; however, I'm starting to see the advantage of having a G on top, which means dropping the low F. Actually, A6 with and E on top seems to fit my brain better. The positions match the "pedals down" position on the E9 pedal steel. Any help you can offer will be appreciated. ------------------ Lee, from South Texas Down On The Rio Grande Mullen U-12, Excel 8-string Frypan, Evans FET-500, Fender Steel King |
Rick Collins Member From: Claremont , CA USA
|
posted 21 June 2006 01:32 PM
profile send email edit
Lee, it seems to me that there are more "possibilities" on the C-6th tuning (fuller chords, more triads and double notes) __ lots of "possibilities" with slant bar.Generally, I see the A-6th as more of a western/swing tuning, E-13th as country and Hawaiian, and C-6th as very Hawaiian and some country. This is only for starting out on non-pedal; ultimately, the player my play any style on any tuning. |
Al Szwarc Member From: New Jersey, USA
|
posted 21 June 2006 01:34 PM
profile send email edit
I am just about the same place you are right now. You might want to check out this site http://hsga.org/learning/tunings.html its a good start for the information you are seeking. I'm sure many of the other forum guys will add some suggestions to your question. I currently have a D8 set with C6 and E13. I have only really done serious attempts on the C6. I was thinking of going to C13 for the other neck so that many of the fret locations would be the same. Can't wait to see all the responses you get. There are so many ways to set up your instrument to suite your playing. Good luck my friend. al =4) |
Andy Hinton Member From: Louisiana, USA
|
posted 21 June 2006 06:32 PM
profile send email edit
Lee; I cant help you much personally but, I suggest you get in touch with Wayne Cox. If you was arround gnashville in the 70s, he was Jack Greene's steeler as well as a couple of other Known artists. Today he plays mostly nonpedal, Mainly the 10 string Steel Gitfiddle which he designed & I built. I'm sure he can help you a lot. Goodluck. Andy H. |
TonyL Member From: Vancouver, BC
|
posted 21 June 2006 07:35 PM
profile send email edit
On my T-8s I use A6, E9, and E13. In general, I use A6 for western swing/ blues / rockabilly. E9 for blues/ country- and some rock and roll. E13 for rockabilly and some swing tunes. However it really depends on the song itself and what key it's in too. Let your ear decide the best tuning. T |
Dan Sawyer Member From: Studio City, California, USA
|
posted 22 June 2006 01:14 AM
profile edit
If you keep an E string on the top of all 3, it will make your life easier. |
Erv Niehaus Member From: Litchfield, MN, USA
|
posted 22 June 2006 07:29 AM
profile send email edit
I heartily agree with Dan. Prior to the pedal steel, my instrument of choice was a T-8 Fender Stringmaster. I never had anything other than an E for the 1st string, on all three necks. As far as the choice of which neck and tuning to play, it all depends on the type of music, the particular piece you are playing and the key it is written in. I'm from the old school having started out on the original A, high bass, Hawaiian tuning so I had to have that on one neck. The second neck was a form of the E tuning, the C#m7, and, of course, you would be considered a heratic if you wouldn't include the C6th on one neck. Jerry Byrd would haunt you if you didn't! Erv |
Danny James Member From: Columbus, Indiana, USA
|
posted 22 June 2006 04:29 PM
profile send email edit
I too started out with the Hawaiian A tuning with the E first string, on the old Harlin Bros. Multi-Kord. I used a 6 string low bass tuning and still do. The low bass is good to play a Boogie, Roaring Valcano, or a lower Steel Guitar Rag part. I have built a single neck lapsteel and designed a changer with 4 tunings. They are--- A,C6th,A6th,& E. I may try some of the tunings you suggest here, and really look forward to seeing the many educational posts you all contribute. :-) |
Denny Turner Member From: Northshore Oahu, Hawaii USA
|
posted 23 June 2006 04:32 AM
profile send email edit
There are many considerations for tunings on a multi-neck, but might I add what helped me allot, particularly in my not too long ago early years on Steel (early 1990's):FWIW: Except for my BR6 I took to my lessons, I practiced and played on a Rick 518 (10-8-8) Console. Since I had been playing slide on the BR6 for many years, I was not afraid to integrate the Steel I was learning into my gigs, on the C518. 33 years of navigating spanish guitar from E notes, had me put E13 on the closest neck; a good tuning for lots of things (plus I was studying Tom Morrell's work), and which also provided me a neck to go to when I got lost (often) on the C6 middle neck or whatever tuning was on the outside neck. For 2 years the outside neck was tuned to whatever tuning I was at in Jerry Byrd's course; But afterward I took a "cue" from a Tom Morrell setup and destrung the outside neck to hold my bar, tuner, boom light, ashtray, drinks ( ON YER STEEL!?!??? ... yea, I was pedal to the metal and pretty loose for what I knew were the last of my better years ...but walked away from it in 2002). After ceasing gigs 4 years ago, at home I would put whatever tunings of the moment / interest on the outside neck and have the other familiar necks to compare with in studying. Although the C518 has been packed away for a couple years now, ...as soon as I get things caught up on around here (ever?), I will pull it back out just so I can study different tunings and have the familiar tunings right there to compare with. Aloha, DT~
[This message was edited by Denny Turner on 23 June 2006 at 04:41 AM.] |
Larry Phleger Member From: DuBois, PA
|
posted 23 June 2006 05:48 AM
profile send email edit
I play a National T8. I use (from front to back) B6, E13 and A6. I mainly play pedal steel (U12) and that makes sense out of the non-pedal setup. The A6 is the same as the A&B pedals down. The B6 is the same as engaging the knee lever that lowers strings 4 and 8. The E13 gives you the advantage of having both a 6th and a 7th available in the no pedal position. |
Todd Clinesmith Member From: Redcrest, California, USA
|
posted 23 June 2006 08:12 AM
profile send email edit
On my triple 8, I have from my inside neck out C13, A6, and E9,13. All with the E on top. This way on each neck I have a 3, a 5 and a one on top. I mostly use the C13 neck since I can find most of my country, westen and Hawaiian tunes and feels on this neck. Second is the E9,13.... then A6.For me, what decides which neck I use is : What key the tune is in. I like to have the widest range of chords avaliable. If the tune is in B flat I may go with the E9,13 since I would be on the 8th fret as opposed to the 10th( C) or 1st and 13th ( E) frets on my other two tunings. Also my 4's,5's,6's,2's ect do not have me leaping all over the neck. My second deciding factor may be . Where the melody of the tune starts. If the melody starts on the 5th note of which ever key were in, I may go with the A6 since I have my 5 on top of my chord. The timbre of the melody is an important factor as well. Sometimes I will work up a tune on one neck and I may fight the melody a bit....one day you try this song on a different neck and it all clicks and works out smoothly. So sometimes it just takes trying all the necks to see what feels right. Time and experience will always settle which tuning fits best for yourself. I hope this is helpfull and not just a bunch of B.S for you. Regardless it works for me, though I may a bit confused my self after writting this. Todd |
Michael Johnstone Member From: Sylmar,Ca. USA
|
posted 23 June 2006 09:43 AM
profile send email edit
On my T-8 Stringmaster from the inside out I have: B6/Ab9 (Murph's tuning tuned down a half-step),G6 (dobro G with added E and C) and on the outside neck I have Tom Morrell's E13 w/out the outside strings. E13 is the one I'm least familiar with but I have worked things up for recording that sounded pretty good - I'm just not real fluent and would never use it on a jam session.I'm playing some E13 on the new Red Simpson CD "The Bard of Bakersfield". If I had to play just one tuning it would be either the Murph tuning or the one I have on my CruzTone which is A13(Junior Brown's tuning but in A). As far as which one I'll go for in a given song,it's not so much about keys but more about intervals and the flavor of the tune.Modal blues,rock and certain cowboy stuff lays easy on the dobro neck while country sounds are easier to get on E13. Murph's and Junior Brown's tunings are "sweeter" and contain tri-tone intervals which means more chord subs and are good for anything - Hawaiian,western swing,pop jazz standards and other "grown-up music". BTW I never got the whole "tune all the 1st strings to E routine" What's that all about? -MJ- |
Danny James Member From: Columbus, Indiana, USA
|
posted 23 June 2006 10:47 AM
profile send email edit
"Tune all the 1st strings to E Routine" ??Michael, On my 6 string lapsteel with the changer I built, here are the tunings that I'm using at the present. (1 to 6--high to low) (low bass tuning) 1 2 3 4 5 6 A tuning --E,C#,A,E,A,E C6th " ---E,C,A,G,A,E E "------E,B,G#,E,B,E A6th "----E,C#,A,F#,A,E I hope this helps. |
Michael Johnstone Member From: Sylmar,Ca. USA
|
posted 23 June 2006 04:17 PM
profile send email edit
I can see what you're doing - getting several tunings out of the same set of strings. But I'm talking about the guys with T-8s that can have any tunings in any keys they want. |
Rick Collins Member From: Claremont , CA USA
|
posted 24 June 2006 09:28 AM
profile send email edit
quote: "tune all the 1st strings to E routine"
Michael, I think it's just a matter of personal preference. I have a triple Fender on which I tune all first strings to E. I just don't like the thin sound of a fine string. But, I can appreciate the versatility of having a string such as the G or G# on top. For one, I believe Jerry Byrd didn't use a fine string on top. Of course he played only a double neck, or a single neck in his early years, so far as I can ascertain from reading. |
basilh Member From: United Kingdom
|
posted 24 June 2006 06:25 PM
profile send email edit
Michael, you ask about the 'All E's" scenario... the fact that you have to ask the question, would seem to indicate, It probably wouldn't apply to you as in all likelihood you're not a guitar player as well. The tunings you list as using would be a combination unique to you. In the case of a Steel Guitarist who is also familiar with regular six string guitar positions, the "All E's" makes a LOT of sense as the positions directly relate to the same frets on either instrument.E13th - C6th and A6, (or better still B11th) would seem to be the general consensus amongst the top echelon, be it Western Swing, Hawaiian or whatever.. IMHO the C6th with a high G is just a duplication of the A6th inversions. Baz (The little 'B')
[This message was edited by basilh on 24 June 2006 at 06:28 PM.] |
Ron Randall Member From: Dallas, Texas, USA
|
posted 24 June 2006 10:27 PM
profile send email edit
FWIW. Neck closest to my jelly-belly is Bb6/Gm7. Same basic tuning as C6/Am7. I do this because my top string is an F. I can use a larger string and get more meat out of the top string. The middle neck is the same basic Bb6 tuning: C top A F D Bb G F D or sometimes Bb bottom This gives me a quick 5 chord on the top three strings, that can slide back to a 4 chord or up to a 6 chord. The C on top is tuned a whole step higher than the Bb. The 2nd string A is tuned a half step lower than the Bb. The 3rd neck, the one farthest from me, is tuned to Leon's E13. I use Eb13 only because it makes sense with the Bb necks. I use the middle neck when playing with a band that does not need any more low notes. I have lots of licks and chords right under the bar. hope this helps Ron |
Michael Johnstone Member From: Sylmar,Ca. USA
|
posted 25 June 2006 12:26 AM
profile send email edit
OK I'm buying the thing where a guitarist could relate chord positions from a guitar to the chord positions among several steel tunings except for the C6 tuning simply because the E chord position on C6 is on the 4th fret. How does that relate to a standard guitar besides the fact that the E note is the maj 3rd of a C chord? Wouldn't a B6 tuning line up better position-wise with an A6,B11 or E13 tuning even tho the first string would be a D#? BTW,I do indeed play guitar and have for 40+ years(I don't know how well anymore). In my mind I guess,a guitar is a guitar and a steel is a steel and that's the beauty of it. Same with a mandolin. Some guitar players tune it in 4ths instead of 5ths to stay in their comfort zone but lose the voicings and range. Vive La Difference. -Johnstone- |
Larry W. Jones Member From: Kingwood, Texas, 77339 The Liveable Forest
|
posted 25 June 2006 01:59 AM
profile send email edit
Time for a "visual" on all this. |
basilh Member From: United Kingdom
|
posted 25 June 2006 03:44 AM
profile send email edit
OK Larry you started it, so you showed me yours, I'll show you mine !!! Michael, the C6th tuning relates to the standard guitar chord shape used to play , for example, Eb at the 3rd fret..But NOT if it the C6th has the high 'G'.
I can't post tab because I'm an ignoramus in that department, I will explain the position on a standard guitar that I'm referring to. 3rd fret 1st string, 4th fret 2nd string, 3rd fret 3rd string, 5th fret 4th string, 6th fret 5th and sixth strings. Finger 1 barre at 3rd and finger 4 playing 5th AND 6th strings. If this explains the chord shape, Great, if it isn't clear then maybe someone can post a "Window Box" of what I mean ? Basing the key on the C6th neck, and assuming the key of Eb, third fret C6th neck = 1 Chord, 4th fret E13th neck = 4 chord, 6th fret E13th = 5 chord, same fret A6/B11 = 1 with a 5th on top. (Top 4 strings only.) Then if we adopt the C6th/A7th, 3rd fret All strings except 6th = Eb, first fret all strings except 2nd = Bb7.Three types of chords available with NO SLANTS... Major Minor and Seventh. And that's just one neck. If we also approach the B11th as a 'Twin Tuning' then we can think of it as A6th and B9th combined and play likewise. This multi-neck multi tuning approach, changing necks for different inversions, is the STANDARD modus operandi amongst the players I know. Using a multi necked guitar just for different tunings dedicated to specific tunes, IMHO, is an alternative to having three guitars with varied tunings, but not optimising the full capabilities of the instrument/tunings.
[This message was edited by Mrs. basilh on 25 June 2006 at 03:50 AM.] [This message was edited by basilh on 25 June 2006 at 08:33 AM.] |
John McGann Member From: Boston, Massachusetts, USA
|
posted 25 June 2006 05:56 AM
profile send email edit
I notice on my Dual Pro that if the pickup selector is on for both necks, the tone really suffers vs. the selector on one neck at a time- do you neck jumpers leave them all on, or switch the swtich as you switch? |
basilh Member From: United Kingdom
|
posted 25 June 2006 08:30 AM
profile send email edit
All on and use a 'Buffer' amp so the tone DOESN'T suffer. If you had to switch each neck on and off, you'd have to half the tempo of everything!! | |