Steel Guitar Strings Strings & instruction for lap steel, Hawaiian & pedal steel guitars http://SteelGuitarShopper.com |
Ray Price Shuffles Classic country shuffle styles for Band-in-a-Box, by BIAB guru Jim Baron. http://steelguitarmusic.com |
This Forum is CLOSED. |
![]() |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
|
This topic is 2 pages long: 1 2 |
next newest topic | next oldest topic |
Author | Topic: Alternative Country... |
Mark Krutke Member From: Tomahawk, WI USA |
![]() At the 2001 ISGC many of us heard a term that was kind of new, at least to me. I believe it was mentioned by Jeff Newman: Alternative Country - and it's gaining popularity. Wait a minute you gray-headed stringpullers....Don't leave this post yet until you understand what "Alternative Country" is!! Did anybody else hear Jeff talk about this? Did he not say this style of music was nothing other than the traditional-style country music that we all love (with a lot of steel) under a different name? The younger crowd might not go for "Old-fashioned Country & Western", but they might go for Alternative Country.... Big Band music is back with the younger generation as well as those who grew up with it, maybe all it would take is a different title to bring our Old-time...I mean alternative music back? Just a thought |
Al Marcus Member From: Cedar Springs,MI USA |
![]() Nice thinking, Mark! Put a new tag on our old country and big band music. That will do it! So what will we name it? It has to be cool and The NOW ......al ![]() ![]() |
rayman unregistered |
![]() Mark, I am in a band with younger guys and we are doing more and more alternative country. Charlie Robison is pretty much recognized as the king of alternative country. Jack Ingram and Steve Earl are some others. Its really more like folk rock. Heavy on the B3 organ but also very friendly to steel guitar and mandolin. We go into rock clubs and hit them with this music. Its almost like Dylan or The Byrds with steel guitar. It is story telling music. Good stuff, but classic listners would probably be turned off by the rock edge. Mylo Deering was playing for Jack Ingram. I love playing it because it blows the doors off the rock bands and opens the door for us to play some Johnny Cash or Waylon Jennings or Merle. After we rock em with alternative country we hit em with "Folsom Prison" or "Think I'll Just Stay Hear And Drink". The young people love it. Even though it is rock oriented, it is very friendly to steel guitar. Something like the Burritto Brothers. If you haven't heard Charlie Robison pick up one of his CD's. Marty Muse and Robby Turner play steel. Natalie Maines (Dixie Chicks)sings a beutiful waltz duet. This music is really where country is going. Like I say the young people love it. [This message was edited by rayman on 08 November 2001 at 10:19 PM.] [This message was edited by rayman on 08 November 2001 at 10:20 PM.] |
Mark Tomeo Member From: Danville, PA USA |
![]() Yeah, but the real hangup with Alternative Country is radio. "Country" radio is like McDonalds - the exact same format coast to coast. The burgers taste the same and the playlists sound the same no matter what state of the nation you're in. Rock or pop radio, on the other hand, is completely fragmented. You have stations that play urban and dance music, adult contemporary, hard rock and metal, soft rock, alternative rock, oldies - why hasn't country radio broken down into different formats? From the comments about the CMA show, it's obvious there's an audience for more than new hot country. I don't understand why country radio hasn't followed the model of rock and pop radio segmenting by audience Country music has certainly imitated the sounds and style of rock and pop music. There ought to be room enough on the airwaves for all tastes. |
Adrian Wulff Member From: Portland, OR, USA |
![]() Alternative country has been around since the late 80's. Bands like Jason and the Scorchers, Uncle Tupelo, Whiskey town, Old 97's, and the Gourds have been mixing up rock,punk, and traditional country sounds with some really good results. A lot of young people have gotten into Buck Owens, Johnny Cash, Merle, and George Jones by listening to these bands. They get played on college and public radio stations across the country. ------------------ |
Mark Tomeo Member From: Danville, PA USA |
![]() Yeah, but college and public radio doesn't count the same way commercial radio does. They're important markets but they're not where country bands break big. Gavin doesn't even chart alternative country, which it used to call "Americana," anymore. It's never going to be the next big thing with country radio as tightly formatted as it is at present. |
John Paul Jones Member From: San Diego |
![]() If you guys want some authentic "alternative" music (Merle, Conway, 'Possum Jones, Tammy, etc.) tune in to a Texas station. You may have to turn the dial a bit but you'll find it. And, they're starting to play more and more of it. Texas...I love it (and Country Music) ------------------ GFI U-12 |
Red Kilby Member From: Pueblo, CO, USA |
![]() Alternative Country, what a novel subject.That is what I have been dub as by the country market place. If you want to check out what they are calling alternative country go to www.google.com then type in my name red kilby. Listen to about 15 seconds of each cut, and let me know what you think?? P.S Check out WHO did my LINER NOTES, you steelers will love this!!!!!!!.If you want a copy let me know???? |
Red Kilby Member From: Pueblo, CO, USA |
![]() P.S.S, by the way Mark I was at the ISGA 2001 and the only alternative country that was played on Jeff's show was when Hal Rugg played the intro to "Ones On the Way" and brought the house down<<<<. That was awsome<<<. |
Mark Tomeo Member From: Danville, PA USA |
![]() Hey Red...I'll check out your site and sound files as soon as I get a chance. I'm not sure what you mean about Jeff's show, Hal Rugg and "One's on the Way," but then I wasn't there. Why would his intro to an old Loretta song be considered alt.country? And JPJ, I know you guys think the rest of the U.S. is just a part of Texas where the people aren't enlightened enough to appreciate barbecue and boots, but we can't get your radio stations no matter how much we turn the dial. |
Paul Graupp Member From: Macon Ga USA |
![]() Now I know what kind of music I'm playing !! I don't have any alternatives !! So that would make this: "My Alternative Country..." Beats not playing and sitting at home waiting for that Halloween Guy with the big sythe (an old Country device used to cut grain for harvest.). Regards, Paul |
Joey Ace Sysop From: Southern Ontario, Canada |
![]() I was part of the discussion with Jeff about ALT-Country, at the 2001 ISGC. Jeff's point was that it is a fact that ALT-COUNTRY, to the radio programming industry, means George Jones, and all the others we consider Country. Equally ironic is that "Country" means (to these industry-types) acts that most of us refer to as "New Country". Most everyone I know thinks "Alt-Country" refers to the current day "outlaws", (the type of bands refered to in Adrian Wulff's above post). That's not true, according to Jeff, the radio industry has defined "Alt-Country" to be what I call "Classic Country". Jeff's main point was the irony of this. This is the first time I've realized that this new "Alt-Country" definition might just be a good thing, as far as marketing traditional country to a younger audience. Like it or not, this young audience has grown up thinking "Country" means the hit Hat-Acts of the 90s. [This message was edited by Joey Ace on 12 November 2001 at 10:38 AM.] |
Chris Schlotzhauer Member From: Colleyville, Tx. USA |
![]() http://www.alternativecountry.com/ |
Steve Stallings Member From: Bremond, Tx, pop 876, Home of the fighting Bremond Tigers |
![]() I played a job recently at a county fair opening and closing for Jack Ingram. He does not play country music of any kind...period. He reminds me of a drunken John Cougar Mellencamp. He didn't have a steel player. I have both of his CD's. There is zero notable steel on these. Charlie Robison on the other hand does play alt-country with tons of steel. ------------------ |
rayman unregistered |
![]() Steve, thats ahame about Jack Ingram. Mylo Deering use to play with him. He was always to rocky for my taste. So much for professionalism. |
Gene Jones Member From: Oklahoma City, OK USA |
![]() When I was first out of highschool I worked with a "union" guitarist/teacher..and I still remember his complaining about the "string-stretchers" guitar players who were "destroying" the music business....does anything ever change? |
Mark Krutke Member From: Tomahawk, WI USA |
![]() Joey Ace mentioned the ideas that came out that night at the convention that I was hoping someone besides myself gathered. I'm sure there are many different definitions (and even a website) for Alternative Country, but this particular meaning that Al Marcus, Joey and I and others comprehend is the meaning of bringing back the classic era of Country music, say from the 50's and 60's and putting the name "Alternative Country" on it, although it may get confused with other styles already named as such. A different name for Classic Country would perhaps be more suitable, but yet the name has to sound "today". It has to appeal!! How about..... "Cool Classic Country" or "Hip-Honky Tonk" |
Jason Odd Member From: Melbourne, Victoria, Australia |
![]() There's also terms like 'Retro-Twang' or Twang core, another term for Alterna-country is the 'No Depression' scene. In the early 1980s there were a series of bands that mixed punk and country and R&B, I suppose you might call that the original Cowpunk scene, Jason & The Scorchers is probably the most famous outfit in that style, while the early Southern culture on The Skids and latter period CDs by the Supersuckers are probably the most current and notable of the crop. Then there were the 'space-country' or the rain parade era of bands, there was a whole series of 1980s groups that seemed to want to mix the sounds of the Byrds, Buffalo Springfield and Neil Young, although not incrediably country, this was a big scene in L.A. for a while there and the general style did spawn some interesting outfits, Rain Parade, The Triffids (Australian), The Long Ryders and others. I suppose one of the most influential 1980s groups would have to be Uncle Tupelo, the name of one of their albums coined the term 'No Depression' and when the group split in the 1990s it produced Son Volt and the much more famous Wilco. Another groundbreaking alt-country act was the Jayhawks, their still around in one form or another,their debut was in the late 1980s and they formed out of various guys who were sick of the punk scene and wanted to play something more along the lines of the Flying Burrito Brothers, but there were heaps of 1980s roots rockers, from Boston, New York, L.A., Miineapolis, etc. Then you've got acts like Big Sandy, the Derailers, the Mavericks (moreso the early albums), the late great Desert Rose Band, Dale Watson, Wayne Hancock, Patty Booker, etc who draw on earlier popular styles of country music for their style and sound, whereas the alterna-country crowd seems to draw more influence from the country-rock era. Of course the Alterna-country scene was also partially built on 1980s folk (lots of cool Texas stuff), old timey music revival bands, and the various Rockabilly and Western Swing revivalists that keep popping up over the years. |
Ally Member From: Edinburgh, UK |
![]() Amazing. A long debate on alt-country, and no-one mentions Gram Parsons, and just one Burittos reference. This must be some kind of record. |
Red Kilby Member From: Pueblo, CO, USA |
![]() Hi Ally, well in my personal opinion, of Gram Parsons the best part of his music was James Burton playing lead guitar and Buddy Emmons playing Steel. He wasn't COUNTRY.Thats like trying to say, that The Byrds were country cause they did the "Sweetheart of the Rodeo" album. The only good part about the LP was Lloyd Green's playing. |
Steve Stallings Member From: Bremond, Tx, pop 876, Home of the fighting Bremond Tigers |
![]() Hmm...can't say I agree that Gram Parsons was not country. "Grievous Angel" sounds pretty country to me. I also liked NRPS at about the same time. The Byrds "Sweethearts of the Rodeo" is my favorite country album period. This and Poco is what got me into this. A little later, PP League caught my fancy. Just goes to show that what some don't consider country, others do. ------------------ |
rayman unregistered |
![]() Steve, I have to agree with you. Grahm Parsons along with Chris Hillman were the ones who synthesized country with folk rock (Roger McGuinn) and the results are to a great extent what you here today on the radio as pop country. Grievous Angel with Neil Flanz on steel and Drug Store Truck Driving man is about as classic traditional country as I know. Cash on the Barrel Head also. Different strokes for different folks. |
Al Marcus Member From: Cedar Springs,MI USA |
![]() When those big wheels, in the radio adn recording industry, hear the words"Classic Country" they close their pocketbooks. So let's call it something else and fool them. How about "Real Country" or "Big Country", anything to get them out of their time warp......al |
Red Kilby Member From: Pueblo, CO, USA |
![]() Hey Steve and Rayman, well like they say everyone has an opinion. I read your comment and had to go and listen to the Grevious Angel album again,and I feel the same as before, He sounds like "A Sick Cat in the bottom of and Oil Barrel" the music behind him is great as is EmmyLou.But he was a wanna be country artist,that should have stuck with Greenwich Village Scene.As far as The Byrds go,Like I said about Gram, they should have stuck with "Turn,Turn,Turn" country was not there bag. Lloyd's playing was the only highlight on the LP,the Music was country,the singers?? "Are you Serious???" |
Mark Krutke Member From: Tomahawk, WI USA |
![]() You got it, Al. Something that'll stick....For example, I know of a recording studio near my home called..Are you ready?...."EXTRA FISH". Yea, a recording studio. I went over to visit the guy who runs it and asked him why call a recording studio "Extra Fish"??? He plainly said, "So people will remember it". I remembered it for sure. That doesn't have much to do with the names we're putting on the old music, but it's just additional food for thought (pun intended). I think I'll go work on my "scales", now. Sorry. Then again there is a method to that madness. They put catchy words in advertising.... A new name for an old item is how things sell. Barrel rings.......hula hoops |
Red Kilby Member From: Pueblo, CO, USA |
![]() P.S. If you want to hear some REAL COUNTRY ,listen to a Mel Street,Faron Young, Moe Bandy,Charley Pride,Merle Haggard,Buck Owens,Dale Watson,Loretta Lynn,Connie Smith or GENE WATSON<<< LP sometime.Then you can hear GOOD PLAYING and GOOD SINGING !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
Jason Odd Member From: Melbourne, Victoria, Australia |
![]() Red, I could not disagree with you more, Sweetheart is basically the first alterna-country album although there are other contenders with the Band, Dylan, The Everly Brothers and the Beau Brummels producing some fine country-ish releases in 1968. It ain't Haggard, Jones, Dave Dudley or Buck Owens, but that's really not the point. ...it's something altogether wonderfully different. To me it's another case of ever evolving and mutation musical genres. |
John Steele Member From: Renfrew, Ontario, Canada |
![]() I'll bypass the personal saga and say this: Re: Gram Parsons - He's a good part of the reason that alot of us under-40 steel players are here. -John |
Steve Stallings Member From: Bremond, Tx, pop 876, Home of the fighting Bremond Tigers |
![]() Yes....I'm serious. I also love Buck, Charlie, George, Dale....ad finitum. I just turned fifty. Ilike Led Zep, ZZ Top,Beatles,Mountain,Third Eye Blind, Three Doors Down,James Taylor,Nat King Cole, Alvin and the Chipmunks, Moody Blues,Cole Porter,Swing Bands, Tom Morrell, Byrds, Eagles, Frank Zappa, Yellowjackets, George Benson, Greatfull Dead,Bach, Three Tenors....... I don't understand folks who limit their musical palate to a narrow diet constantly. All music is a joyous noise.... ------------------ |
Red Kilby Member From: Pueblo, CO, USA |
![]() 1st off I don't limit myself , my absolute favorite music of all time is, late 50's early 60's Doo-Wop harmony singing. And I like the rock bands of the 70's,like Styx,and Boston. But I was just stating my opinion on their singing ability. And while I am stating my opinion,I would not consider The Byrds or Gram Parsons "Alternative Country" they are FOLK plain pure and Simple. |
Red Kilby Member From: Pueblo, CO, USA |
![]() P.S. Thats what I love about America, You can have an OPINION and state it<<<<<. |
Steve Stallings Member From: Bremond, Tx, pop 876, Home of the fighting Bremond Tigers |
![]() Hey, I like Styx and Boston too....LOL ------------------ |
Jim Peter Member From: Mendon,Mich USA |
![]() I play in a band that sounds similar to Rayman's. We have Fiddle, Steel & Dobro, Bass and a Rhythm guitar player. We do everything from Old Country, to Bluegrass, a gospel tune, some Big Sandy, a Dylan song, a little Gershwin and quite a bit of Greatful Dead (Our band's name is 'Cumberland Blues', a title of a GD song). We play a lot in the Kalamazoo Mich area, which is a fun little college town, and the response we get from these kids is tremendous. The minute we kick off ET's "Thanks a Lot" these kids are going wild. I am the youngest member of the band at 50, but no one seems to mind. The last time we played downtown I went looking for our bass player who happened to be hanging out with a cute little co-ed in her early 20's. When she saw me she complimented me on my steel playing, mentioned that she has an alt-country band and would I like to sit in with her band sometime. I looked at her, looked over at my wife and decided that maybe that was one project I should probably not take on. When people ask us what kind of music our band plays we really don't know what to say, but maybe alt-country would fit the bill. At least it sounds cool. |
Jim Smith Member From: Plano, TX, USA |
![]() When they ask me what kind of music I play, I say "both kinds, Country AND Western!" ![]() ------------------ |
Ray Jenkins Member From: Gold Canyon Az. Pinal U.S.A. |
![]() I'm playing with a band called S.T.A.R.R. Still Ticking After Rock and Roll.We play Do- Wop,Rightious Bros.,Latino and Country ect.. What I like about this band, they do not call themselves country or even try to prostalize the great country name.We just play a lot of different "MUSIC".I have really got into the Latino stuff,real fun to play, a lot to experiment with on the steel,very similar too cajun,lots of fast single string stuff. Again they don't ride the coatails of the word "Country".Believe me guys,I'm country to the bone,love it and always will. Ray ------------------ [This message was edited by Ray Jenkins on 16 November 2001 at 11:55 AM.] [This message was edited by Ray Jenkins on 16 November 2001 at 12:02 PM.] [This message was edited by Ray Jenkins on 16 November 2001 at 12:03 PM.] |
Jason Odd Member From: Melbourne, Victoria, Australia |
![]() quote: That would be simply no... I'm not really interested in arguing the point, but I don't think that Gram's two albums with the FBBs or his solo albums are folk by any stretch, I'd say the Byrd's Sweetheart album has folkish leanings, and I admit that Gram's stint with the Byrds still had some folkie overtones; especially when compared his work with the Flying Burrito Brothers the following year. But if we want to talk the roots of alterna-country.. I was actually intentionally avoiding mentioning Gram at first, but his contemporaries include: [This message was edited by Jason Odd on 17 November 2001 at 08:43 AM.] |
rayman unregistered |
![]() Hey Jim Peter, if you guys are doing ET's "Thanks Alot" you've got great taste!It just goes to show you that good country is classic and will never die. We get the same reaction out of "Running Kind" by Merle Haggard. Its a little strange at 48 years old to see these young people partying to this music, but I am lucky to be playing with excellent players. Jason you are very knowledgable. Red, I thoroughly respect your opinion. [This message was edited by rayman on 17 November 2001 at 03:55 PM.] |
Jason Odd Member From: Melbourne, Victoria, Australia |
![]() Red, sorry man,I'm not trying to dis you... I respect what you're saying, but I guess G.P. loyalty is kinda on the strong side. On an interesting side note, I was just listening to the CD reissue of the Woody Guthrie 'Dust Bowl Ballads' set from 1940, then I listened to the Byrds' version of Guthrie's song "Pretty Boy Floyd" which was originally cut by Guthrie on the Ballads series, then... I listened to the two Guthrie 'Mermaid Avenue' tribute series where Alt-country group Wilco and singer/songwriter Billy Bragg interpret a series of songs ol' Woody never got to record. |
CHIP FOSSA Member From: Monson, MA 01057 U.S.A. |
![]() The Byrds, in all of their manifestations, and off-shoot groups as well, demonstrated beyond a doubt, what real creativity is; something sorely lacking in MOST of today's "music". Every album, one after the other, that the Byrds came out with, was as different as Raid and Right Guard. They took chances and stuck their necks out, musically. It's music, man, and excellent music at that. No need to compare or analyze it. Like it, or don't like it. Let it stand on it's OWN merits. The Byrds & Dylan probably were/are the most I just had to jump in here. FWIW. ChipsAhoy |
Bill Llewellyn Member From: San Jose, CA |
![]() I looked up the www.alternativecountry.com link and found a lot of CDs listed but no song samples I could listen to online. Where do I go to get a taste of what y'all are talking about? ------------------ |
This topic is 2 pages long: 1 2 All times are Pacific (US) | next newest topic | next oldest topic |
![]() |
Note: Messages not explicitly copyrighted are in the Public Domain.
Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.46