Steel Guitar Strings Strings & instruction for lap steel, Hawaiian & pedal steel guitars http://SteelGuitarShopper.com |
Ray Price Shuffles Classic country shuffle styles for Band-in-a-Box, by BIAB guru Jim Baron. http://steelguitarmusic.com |
This Forum is CLOSED. |
![]() |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
|
This topic is 2 pages long: 1 2 |
next newest topic | next oldest topic |
Author | Topic: Best Country Rock Band? |
Jason Odd Member From: Melbourne, Victoria, Australia |
![]() By 1978 country-rock was dead, that simple. Sure there were bands doing it, but most of them morphed into a more mainstream urband sound (The Burrito Brothers, etc) In the mid 1980s a series of post-punk bands picked up the sound, some went for the FBBs-Byrds-Parsons-Gene Clark thing, others were a little more into the psyche folk-rock thing (Byrds-Buffalo Springfield), these paisley pop type bands, the ones that followed the latter were the first to really cut records, although the former had one great champion, the Jayhawks who were really the first Alt-Country band in the 1980s. The Outlaw sound and it's followers were far removed from country-rock, and that evolved into the Urban Cowboy sound, which got as cookie-cutter as anything on the charts now. The Cosmic Cowboy things ran along a strangely wonderful path blending singer-songwriter, progressive country (which Willie and Waylon were helping evolve) and even old school Texan folkies like Townes Van Zandt, Guy Clark etc, who straddled the folk and country genres. Picking the first country-rock record is tricky, most of the bands had a blend of country, folk, Bluegrass, folk-rock, psyche-pop, sunshine pop and baroque pop. I never thought of Gene Clark's debut album cut with the Gosdin Brothers as country-rock, it's psyche country at best, although three songs come in as country-rock in general and as a 1967 release are early contenders. Still, the Byrds were mixing peadl steel and country into their sound at the same time anyway. The albums that are almost country-rock are: And quite a few Creedence Clearwater Revival albums. In a way the rockabilly element was stronger. The earliest country-rock albums, by the artist's first country-rock release only: The International Submarine Band - Safe At Home (1968) Nashville West gets a mention, a fantastic recording and group circa 1967, but excluded due to it's late release, 1979. While The As the 1970s progressed we had (some of these have already been mentioned in other posts of course): The Dillards (who went fully country-rock in the 1971-1973 period), Rio Grande, New Riders, Asleep At The Wheel, Muleskinner, Goose Creek Symphony, Commander Cody & The Lost Planet Airmen, Michael Nesmith and the Second National Band, the Countryside Band), Swampwater, Barefoot Jerry, the Charlie Daniels Band, Southern Comfort, Heads Hands & Feet, The Dingoes, Mason Proffit, Rick Nelson & The Stone Canyon Band, Jonathan Edwards, the Eagles, Redwing, Pure Praire League, Souther Hillman Furay, Emmylou Harris & The Hot Band, Clover, Cherokee, Country Funk, Boondoggle and Balderdash, Possum, Redeye, Manassas and Country Radio among others. I'm sure there's others I've forgotten. |
Jason Odd Member From: Melbourne, Victoria, Australia |
![]() In regards to the Greatful Dead, I really love their two 1970 albums, but they don't really qualify as country-rock as such, however I did fail to mention them. The closest Neil Young came to country-rock was Harvest (1972), but if we were going to include all the country infused singer-songwriter records and the Cosmic Cowboy stuff, well.. this would be huge. The Jerry Jeff Walker live album from 1973 with Herb Steiner is a fantastic bridge between country-rock, progressive country and the whole Cosmic Cowboy thang. Another exclusion is the wonderful Flatlanders, whose stripped back mostly acoustic country LP from 1972 only came out in a limited run on 8-track, it came out on proper release over a decade later and reamins in print. |
David Doggett Member From: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA |
![]() I like Billy J's idea for a festival. I'd sure try to talk my rockabilly/alt-country band into going down. In addition to the rockabilly, punkabilly, and alt-country stuff, we play one Ray Price, Haggard or George Jones song per set, but not the original arrangement. And that brings up Grant J's point that what has been labelled alt-country for the past couple of decades is really just a post-punk continuation of country-rock. His list leaves out a few prominent alt-country groups that are now defunct, such as Uncle Tupelo. The Charlie Daniels band and the Outlaw contingent raise the question of the definition of country-rock. In the English language, the descriptor comes in front of the noun. So country-rock would be rockers playing with country influence, and rock-country would be country pickers playing with a rock influence. The latter is what everyone seems to be complaining about on the Opry for the past few years. I tend to think of the CD Band as rock-country, but that's arguable. I tend to define country-rock as having a lot of good steel, but maybe a lot of good fiddle should also qualify. So I never really thought of the Dead as country-rock, they were just eclectic acid rockers to me (not that there's anything wrong with that). But of course many of the classic country-rock groups mentioned above didn't always have steel on their numbers. |
Alvin Blaine Member From: Sandy Valley, Nevada, USA |
![]() What about "The Earl Scruggs Review"? To me they were a mix of bluegrass, folk, country, blues, and rock. |
Jim Cohen Member From: Philadelphia, PA |
![]() I think a lot of the so-called "country-rock" sound was foreshadowed by the Lovin' Spoonful... |
Grant Johnson Member From: Nashville TN |
![]() quote: A great example of a pop group dipping their toes in the country waters! Nashville Cats and Darling Companion are two songs that definitely have a bit of that swingy country rock bounce. Del McCoury Band played "Nashville Cats" last time I saw them, it made a fine Bluegrass song as well! |
Webb Kline Member From: Bloomsburg, PA |
![]() Jason, that's quite a compilation for someone who doesn't even live in the US!! Wow! I've always grouped CDB, Marshall Tucker, Allman Bros., Barefoot Jerry, The Outlaws, etc as Southern Rock; I guess because they are from the South. NRPS, PPL, Poco, Souther, Hillman, Furay, Eagles, etc. I always considered country rock or desert rock as some have coined them. As for innovative music soon melding into pop garbage, I guess this happens whenever the industry tries to capitalize on something new. Was was once artisitc expression is replaced by a formula to make money and the soul of it is soon diminished. |
David Cobb Member From: Chanute, Kansas, USA |
![]() The Ozark Mt. Daredevils. Grinders Switch. The Greatful Dead. |
Billy T. Johnson Member From: Statesboro, Georgia, USA |
![]() I did sound for CDB about 7 years back and they were slightly more southern rock than coungtry rock but they do touch on country rock at least IMHO. They were tight and did a great show. Charlie is a nice man, very friendly. billy ------------------ |
Jason Odd Member From: Melbourne, Victoria, Australia |
![]() Charlie Daniels band country pickers originally, no I don't think they were. Taz and Charlie were from R&B and rock bands from the 1960s, Charlie went to Nashville in 1967, but by defination geography does not make on a country picker. In 1970 he actually had his band with one of the Youngbloods, it predated the CDB and a live album was rejected, but appeared on a dodgy semi-bootleg label as two different albums in 1976. A lot of Nashville dudes were R&B, soul and rock pickers who hit town between 1964-1973, it took them a while to come into their own, but most of them would be names you'd recognise: Wow, I forgot the Earl Scruggs review and the Ozark Mountain Daredevils, those guys punched out albums of good quality right through the 1970s. The Southern-rock thing is interesting, more bluesy, although Dickey Betts first solo album and Cowboy (great group who I forgot, their debut was 1970) were definately country-rock classics, just more southern. |
Rich Weiss Member From: Woodland Hills, CA, USA |
![]() quote: The best year ever... |
Webb Kline Member From: Bloomsburg, PA |
![]() I saw CDB last year and they were more like a prog rock band than anything. I've heard them a number of times, but they were amazing this last time. Charlie had some kids on guitar that was flat out smokin.' |
Jason Odd Member From: Melbourne, Victoria, Australia |
![]() Rich, yeah and when you add Steve Young's debut and Neil Young's first album with Crazy Horse, whew! |
Theresa Galbraith Member From: Goodlettsville,Tn. USA |
![]() Poco & Eagles |
Jerry Overstreet Member From: Louisville Ky |
![]() I can't really rate them by number. I have most of the stuff already listed above. I guess if I look at my LP pile, I see most of the things that the FBB did, quite a bit of the girls stuff listed, and many things that might be considered esoteric. My biggest stack of a single group is the Amazing Rhythm Aces, although I don't think they really qualify as a Country Rock Band specifically. I mean their music runs the gamut from bluegrass to blues, latin rhythms and more. I think I own all their stuff up through the '90's. including the disco influenced music of the 70's. Barry "Byrd" Burton and Duncan Cameron [late of Sawyer Brown] supplied pedal steel, slide and dobro licks. Jim Vest did the honors on Chock Full of Country issued in the 90's. Somewhere in the 70's I got to see ARA along with PPL and FBB at the same concert. I was tickled like a kid at Christmas! [This message was edited by Jerry Overstreet on 05 February 2005 at 11:39 AM.] |
Billy T. Johnson Member From: Statesboro, Georgia, USA |
![]() yep, 1969 was a GREAT year!!! great music, started college, grew my hair longer! if you can stand it, my picture in 1969 is posted on my web site www.grievousangelpro.com . if you go rthere check my GP page also. billy ------------------ |
Pete Burak Member From: Portland, OR USA |
![]() Webbs County Rock vs Southern Rock list is pretty much in line with my take on it, although there is a significant song-to-song crossover. For example, Ramblin' Man might be concidered the all time County Rock anthem of the 70's, whereas Sweet Home Alabama might be the Southern Rock anthem of the period (my yardstick... you can play steel to Ramblin' Man, but it don't sound remotly fitting in Sweet Home). I think of Southern rock as being a little more rocked out ie. ZZ Top, Blackfoot (Train Train), Skynard, etc. Did anyone mention "Kingfish"? They did tunes like Big Iron, Wild Northland (no steel but definatly in the x-over C-R vein). |
Chris Bauer Member From: Nashville, TN USA |
![]() Lotta GREAT bands mentioned here. I'm surprised to see only one mention each of Goose Creek Symphony and Heartsfield. (Also, is the absence of Pure Prairie League citations because we've all had to play Aime waaaaay too often???) Thanks, Jason, for mentioning the Ian Mathews Southern Comfort album. I've always thought that it was one of the more unfortunately overlooked albums of that era. Though perhaps more folk/country than rock, I always thought it was brilliant and has some terrific Red Rhodes playing on it. (Also, aren't there some some other Charlie Daniels sessions from the Bay Area c.early 70s floating around?) Also Jason, I was interested in your mention of Redwing. Other than their periodic use of Timothy Schmidt, I guess I never thought of them in the country-rock family. They were a terrific band live, though. Frequently electrifying. I always thought it was a shame that their recordings were so lame, all the more so knowing how great they were live. Depending on how inclusive one's definition of country-rock is, I'd wanna also include some of the early 'cow punk' bands like Rank & File, True West, etc., as well as the hippie country bands like Clover. Even more though, I'd include the tougher-to-catagorize bands like the deperately under-known Dusty Chaps. [This message was edited by Chris Bauer on 05 February 2005 at 07:39 PM.] |
Bob Doran Member From: Ames, Iowa, USA |
![]() Don't forget Mason Profitt. Large list of hits, totally unique sound, and fair amount of pedal steel. I loved that band. Bob |
Mike Headrick Member From: Jasper, TN, USA |
![]() To Rolling Stone magazine, The Desert Rose Band played the best Rock and Roll at the time (80's & 90's). To me they played pure Country Rock with a genuine love showing through for traditional country music. Chris Hillman has never lost his touch or taste, and is still involved in recording authentic Country Rock today. Chris & Herb (Pedersen)are still incorporating some fine country rock tracks into their projects. As a matter of fact, it's pretty much the Desert Rose Band without John Jorganson, just with more Bluegrass. They still get JayDee on their sessions, play lots of dates here and abroad, but they don't have to worry about radio comerciality. California Country Rock remains one of the greatest, freshest movements ever to come along, and the thread that Chris Hillman has unraveled through more than four decades is still spooling off. What a monster influence he has been and still is! |
Jason Odd Member From: Melbourne, Victoria, Australia |
![]() Rank & File, yeah cowpunk, that's why I differentiate between country-rock and what followed. Most of the new groups took on a post-punk approach, just as the country-rockers took a post Dylan-Beatles apporoach to their generation's music. Of course alt-country has it's roots in Texas folk, as does country-rock, but that's a whole 'nother topic. The first Redwing recordings, they'd be the ones I'd call country-rock with a psyche influence (most of them had been in a psyche-baroque pop outfit that was aligned with Terry Melcher, ex-Byrds producer), after REdwing's debut, the country element decreased quite noticably by the second album and ever increasingly on each subsequent effort. Most of the country-rock bands got weaker after the first couple of albums due to defections and in the first wave most of them split because they couldn't shift records. Definately a cult genre until the Eagles cracked it. Not to say there wasn't hits, but the real sellers of the late 1960s and early 1960s were hard rock, heavy blues, funk, jazz-rock, etc. |
Chris Bauer Member From: Nashville, TN USA |
![]() I can't believe I neglected to mention Joe Ely whose first couple of albums, it seems to me, had an interesting roost combining country, rock, the Texas singer-songwriter thing & punkness. Glorious and - at the time - unique stuff, I always thought. |
Gary Meyer Member From: Sacramento, California, USA |
![]() Gotta mention Leon Russell's "Hank Wilson" series and Tracy Nelson's later works. Also ,possibly the most commercialy successful album of the country rock genre, "Nashville Skyline". |
Dave Burr Member From: Tyler, TX |
![]() Good point Chris! "Honky Tonk Masquerade" (1978)is my all time favorite Joe Ely album and certainly fits within the Country Rock genre IMHO. Listen to Lloyd Maines on "Boxcars"... Now THAT'S what I call rock and roll steel guitar!!! Respectfully, [This message was edited by Dave Burr on 07 February 2005 at 09:19 AM.] |
Billy T. Johnson Member From: Statesboro, Georgia, USA |
![]() i had a country rock band in ~ 1994 with the name Cosmic Cowboys. billy ------------------ |
Mark Lind-Hanson Member From: San Francisco, California, USA |
![]() I am going to weigh in with folks t say the Grateful Dead were NOT a per se, COuntry rock band. What they were in my opinion was a great SPACE JAZZ band- with coutry influences. But it was NEVER their entire focus, which was, on improvisations nonpariel in ANY kind of genre. Country & bluegrass were certainly in their influences(esp. for Garcia), but, only two of Many. They were a psychedelic rock band, a folk-rock band, a jazz band, a pop-song band, all of these & probably people can bring up more genres they touched on in 30 years. Just to include them as country rock is tangential to what they were all about, (I think.)-especially if you compare them to all these OTHER folks being mentioned. |
Craig Stock Member From: Westfield, NJ USA |
![]() Yes, Joe Ely, 'Honky Tonk Masquerade' 'West Texas Waltz'was played in Lubbock at every Bar Honky Tonk, great steel and Ponty Bone's accordian. |
David Doggett Member From: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA |
![]() Oh man, I am being reminded of so much stuff I had forgotten about. Rank and File, what a band - one of my all time favorites. After I got their album, I got to see them live in the basement of some club in LA - awesome show. And all that great Joe Ely stuff, how could we forget. I'm also happy to hear about some groups I missed out on. [This message was edited by David Doggett on 07 February 2005 at 09:45 PM.] |
Jason Odd Member From: Melbourne, Victoria, Australia |
![]() I have to agree that the 'Dead' were not a country-rock band, there's two 1970 albums that are that nature, although psyche-country might be a little closer and there was more of a blues structure to some of the material. Real fine albums though. (American Beauty and Workingman's Dead) I personally have a hard time nailing the best or fave country-rock outfit, most of them only had a few good albums, and quite a few okay ones. For me, this goes for all of them. Might have been an awesome live band, (the 1969 and 1970 offical live albums are very good), but McGuinn was the weak link in many ways. I'd also link to suggest that Dylan's Nashville Skyline is not even a candidate for a country-rock album, it's a folk singer putting on a country voice and cutting a country album. Nashville Skyline, to me is a retreat from the stunning lyrics and stripped down approach of his 1968 album. This lacks the spirited feel of the Beau Brummels mixing folk pop with Nashville session guys, the eclectic charm that Ian & Sylvia brought to their 1968 Nashville LP, in feel it's like Dylan singing over Doc Watson's 1968 full Nashville backing band set, but wihtout Doc's cool guitar. It did however sell a lot of vinyl and the single 'Lay, Lady Lay' was a hit, so a lot of college students had some nice mood music while trying to ... woo someone. I still think it's a nice record. |
Nate LaPointe Member From: Los Angeles, California, USA |
![]() Burrito Bros/GP Grateful Dead Wilco/Uncle Tupelo NRPS ------------------ |
Bob Doran Member From: Ames, Iowa, USA |
![]() MASON PROFITT. INCREDIBLE BAND. |
Dave Van Allen Member From: Doylestown, PA , US , Earth |
![]() My faves in order: Bands: 1. POCO 2. POCO 3. POCO 4. FBB 5. Stone Canyon Band 6. Mike Nesmith w/ Red Rhodes Albums |
frank rogers Member From: usa |
![]() Area Code 615. |
This topic is 2 pages long: 1 2 All times are Pacific (US) | next newest topic | next oldest topic |
![]() |
Note: Messages not explicitly copyrighted are in the Public Domain.
Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.46