Steel Guitar Strings
Strings & instruction for lap steel, Hawaiian & pedal steel guitars
http://SteelGuitarShopper.com
Ray Price Shuffles
Classic country shuffle styles for Band-in-a-Box, by BIAB guru Jim Baron.
http://steelguitarmusic.com

This Forum is CLOSED.
Go to bb.steelguitarforum.com to read and post new messages.


  The Steel Guitar Forum
  Electronics
  Floor vs amp stand

Post New Topic  
your profile | join | preferences | help | search

next newest topic | next oldest topic
Author Topic:   Floor vs amp stand
John Cox
Member

From: Bryan, Texas, USA

posted 18 January 2006 04:51 PM     profile     
I've seen alot of players set their amps on the floor than having the amp set on a stand where the speaker is directly pointing at them. I was wondering if there is any adavntage to this. I notice a big differance in tone and sound in relation to where my speakers are aimed (I'm running 2 112's). thanks, J.C.
Eric West
Member

From: Portland, Oregon, USA

posted 18 January 2006 05:58 PM     profile     
You're certainly in a league above me JC, but I've always found that if I point my amp or amps away from my ears and add the right amount of high edge, that it doesn't twist my eye teeth out from the highs.

For me, it's got to be brighter than I hear it right next to the amp, or it comes out muddy in front. I've gone to see countless guys that it seems clear at the rig, but muddy out front.

If a gig isn't miked, I don't see how it could be loud enough halfway out in the hall and not make your ears bleed sitting three feet away from it.

EJL

Hook Moore
Member

From: South Charleston,West Virginia

posted 18 January 2006 06:12 PM     profile     
I agree with Eric
Hook

------------------
www.HookMoore.com

Roger Francis
Member

From: Indiana, USA

posted 18 January 2006 08:39 PM     profile     
For me it depends on where i"m playing, if it"s an outside gig i usally put them on the floor behind me slightly tilted, but in an average club that we play in i put them on stands, one at each shoulder 2-3ft pointing past me, mainly because we are a loud band and that helps me keep my tone in my ears and it does get loud at times. I don't like playing that loud but i have to keep up with the Tele's and the bass.
John Cox
Member

From: Bryan, Texas, USA

posted 18 January 2006 09:39 PM     profile     
Here's where I'm having the problem. On the bandsatnd the other night, everything sounded fine. At practice I had a good low volume sound but, when I really "cranked it" the tone got too bright. And I didn't tuch the tone knobs. Since I'm going direct out to the board, could it be there or maybe the differnce in rooms? J.C.
Tony Prior
Member

From: Charlotte NC

posted 19 January 2006 02:47 AM     profile     
Many items can effect what is sounds like out front, one being the dispersion factor of the speaker..

One of the biggest issues I have noticed with Steel players is that they place an amp directly behind them, and set it up to taste.

It sounds awesome behind the..

but thats where it ends. The sound cannot get past there bodies !

What I have done, when we have the room ( even if we don't) I have gone to two amps almost exclusively now. Not two 112's , two of the big brothers. Session 400 and Nashville 400. One is sort of behind me aimed kinda toward me and across the bandstand kind of like a monitor, the other is set up to be unobstructed for stage presence..meaning nothing is in the way of the speaker dispersion.

12" speakers are great, but they don't disperse like 15" in a larger room, especially if the amp is setup behind a player sitting down and the sound can't get past the sitting players back.( or butt)

In very large rooms we mic either one of the amps...I am not an advocate of to many Instruments in the floor wedges..so I , we, refrain from that..I prefer to BEND my ear to listen to the the other players rather than to have all the music in my face..It forces me to lay back a bit more..especially on the right foot...


oh, and I do raise the amps, generally with a 6 or 7 inch plastic tupperware sort of step stool( Wallmart $3.00) and sometimes up about 18 or 20 inches on the custom amp stands/dolly's that we made...When it's a one amp situation that is when I use the higher stand...

But I have noticed, having the amps on the floor, raised 6 inches or raised 18 inches..the same bad notes keep showing up

t


[This message was edited by Tony Prior on 19 January 2006 at 02:53 AM.]

Jack Stoner
Sysop

From: Inverness, Florida

posted 19 January 2006 03:32 AM     profile     
I've always elevated my amps - been doing it since I started playing pedal steel in 1969. If it's behind me or just to the side of me and slightly pointing at me I can tell how loud I am. If it's on the floor the sound goes under you and you can't tell whether or not you are too loud.

It's never affected my "sound", judging from the many great comments I get on my tone, either front or back of the room.

Chris LeDrew
Member

From: Newfoundland, Canada

posted 19 January 2006 04:44 AM     profile     
I just bought an amp stand after many months of procrastinating.......and I'm glad I did. Now I don't have to constantly search the venue for a milk carton, road case, or a wall on which to rest my amp. It goes behind a bit to my left, so I can monitor my pitch without blowing away the rest of the band.

At first I laid my amp on the floor all the time, but I couldn't hear it well enough to play accurately. The sound got lost in the drums or guitar amps. But's it's just as bad to have your amp right up in your face. You have no idea how loud it is on stage when you're that close. A bit behind me, pointed diagonal seems to be the best for me.

By the way, I can't remember the last time I played a gig without the amp miked. I hear of guys talking about that all the time, but I haven't played an unmiked amp gig in years, unless it's an informal house party or something.

Larry King
Member

From: Watts, Oklahoma, USA

posted 19 January 2006 04:45 AM     profile     
To Eric....so as to not be confused, there is John Cox from Bryan, Tx and there is JOHNNIE Cox from Eustace, Tx (I hope I spelled useless correctly). I haven't met John but I've had the joy/priviledge to play bass behind Johnnie, especially at the Tulsa show(Memorial Day weekend---plug, plug). Johnnie Cox would not be asking that question (no offense John) since he has his you know what together. Again, not being a smarty or offensive....Johnnie plays better bass than me and still remains humble about it.
Parr Bryan
Member

From: Texas USA

posted 19 January 2006 08:38 AM     profile     
I put my amp (Nash 400) on a 3ft box and may tilt it depending on the room, always miked and will try direct box next gig.

The sound i get next to amp is muddy with bass but sounds good at 20+ feet away. A 25ft patch cord with amp 25ft away is a good way to hear what it sounds like at distance. I had to cut the highs WAY DOWN because on the floor the treble was killin' ears, opps.

------------------

Ken Fox
Member

From: Ray City, GA USA

posted 19 January 2006 09:19 AM     profile     
Like Tony I run two amps, almost the same as he does. I used to listen to our jam session players up in Washington and noticed any amps tilted back sounded better on stage but the othere player with his 4-10 Bassman could be heard far better out front. His was just sat on the floor! Sitting in on a wooden stage often amplifies the low end! He would roll the bass down to 2 or even off. He always got the best tone out front. Still on stage the other amps sounded better.
David Doggett
Member

From: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA

posted 19 January 2006 10:17 AM     profile     
If your amp is miked and you are only using it for a monitor, then I guess it doesn't matter where you put it, or how you have the tone set. You are in no way controlling how it sounds out front, volumewize or tonewize; the sound man is.

If it is not miked (and most small clubs where I play don't mike the guitar amps), your amp needs to be placed the same as the lead guitar player's amp. Most have theirs some distance behind them, pointing directly out at the audience. Maybe the floor boosts the bass a little, but that's what the bass tone knob is for. Raising the amp for a clearer shot at the audience seems a good idea, especially if the stage is low (some small clubs don't even have stages). On a very high stage you may need to raise the amp just to keep the front edge of the stage from blocking the sound path to the audience. But I don't see the point of tilting an amp up, unless you are trying to project to a balcony or to the rafters. The idea is to point the amp at the head level of the audience, directed to the center of the back wall. If the guitar player's amp is 10 feet behind him pointing at the audience, and your amp is 3 feet behind you pointing at your head, then you will play quieter than he will (because you are hearing your amp louder than he hears his), and you will be lost in the mix out front. If you put your amp toward the back of the stage like the guitar and bass amps and you cannot hear your intonation, then you are simply not playing loud enough. Having perfect intonation is useless if you are the only one who can hear it. I have seen many steelers play with their amp pointed at their head. It is very frustrating, because out front you can't hear them, and they don't seem to have a clue.

Oh yes, and our ears are more sensitive to high frequencies. Feeling that bass thump in your chest feels good, But that ice pick in the ear from the guitarist or steeler playing up the neck does not feel good. Generally, the louder you turn the volume, the more you have to turn down the highs. It does complicate things in that the highs are more directional. Off to one side they may be too quiet, while directly out front they may be too loud. The best remedy for that is multiple speakers pointed in different directions.

[This message was edited by David Doggett on 19 January 2006 at 10:27 AM.]

Gene Jones
Member

From: Oklahoma City, OK USA

posted 19 January 2006 10:38 AM     profile     
*

[This message was edited by Gene Jones on 20 January 2006 at 04:58 AM.]

David Wren
Member

From: Placerville, California, USA

posted 19 January 2006 02:14 PM     profile     
I always put my amp (or amps) on milk crates, if using one amp I try to put it to the right of me, angling to the center stage (and across my pickup). This gets it away from my back, helps a little with sustain (it seems), and channels some steel to the rest of the band. 90% of the time I'm mic'ed off, with explicit directions to the sound person to NOT put steel in the monitors (my reason for this is trying to not interfer with the vocalists monitoring their voices). If it's really a large room or outdoor venue, and we're spread apart on stage, band mates are free to ask for a little steel in their particular monitor.

If I'm on for more than one set I like to use two amps (just got a second Session 500).

------------------
Dave Wren
'95Carter S12-E9/B6,7X7; Twin Session 500s; Hilton Pedal; Black Box
www.ameechapman.com


Ford Cole
Member

From: Texas

posted 19 January 2006 05:59 PM     profile     
How about a Walker Stereo Steel system? Isn't this what you're talking about, ie. two speakers available to feed different areas of the stage?
David Doggett
Member

From: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA

posted 19 January 2006 10:13 PM     profile     
Yep, using a head cabinet and two speakers is definetly more flexible than a combo. And carrying one 25 lb. speaker in each hand is way easier than carrying a 75 lb. combo. Some steelers are also using two Peavey NV112s.
jim milewski
Member

From: stowe, vermont

posted 20 January 2006 06:31 AM     profile     
the deflection of hard floors seems to give unwanted overtones, so tilted or on a box works for me
Brad Sarno
Member

From: St. Louis, MO USA

posted 20 January 2006 06:53 AM     profile     
I'd say #1, keep the "beam" from pointing straight at your ears or you'll pay for it in the long run. That bright, trebly beam that shoots straight out from a speaker is brutal on the eardrums. I like a milk crate so the speaker is blowing at my gut so I can feel the sound. That also lets it be a bit more clear, but still the "beam" is below the eardrums. I haven't had as much success as others with the amp on the floor. It gets kind of boomy and lost most of the time. Also, If I'm miked and want to be heard in the PA system, be sure that you are sitting between the soundman and the speaker. If the soundman has the "beam" pointed right at him, he'll think it's loud when it really isn't and he'll turn you down in the house. That "beam" can kill a turkey at a 100 yards. Much less your ears at one.

Brad

Chick Donner
Member

From: North Ridgeville, OH USA

posted 21 January 2006 01:04 PM     profile     
I set mine up behind me, usually at a slight angle toward the rest of the band, unless we're mic'ed into the PA. I used to have to find chairs for this, or carry them with me, but ever since I began to use Woody Woodell amp covers (30 years or so), I just set the amps or speaker cabinets on the covers, and I'm good to go.
Gordon Borland
Member

From: San Antonio, Texas, USA

posted 21 January 2006 03:26 PM     profile     
I use a steel king on the floor no tilt.
What I hear is the overall mix better this way.
For years I put the Nashville 400 on a chair
behind me. Staying correct in the mix off the bandstand was hit or miss. Iam not a pro
but for me the Fender steel king on the floor works best.

------------------
Gordon Borland
MSA D10,FENDER STEEL KING, NASHVILLE 400,PEAVEY SESSIONS 2000, 1963 BROWN FENDER DELUXE NO REVERB. 1973 FENDER JAGUAR SUNBURST SIX STRING GUITAR, PEAVEY T60 SIX STRING GUITAR.


Ken Byng
Member

From: Southampton, England

posted 21 January 2006 03:37 PM     profile     
2 Nashville 400's - I have one on a stand and one on the floor on the other side of the stage. That way I get the best of both worlds.
T. C. Furlong
Member

From: Vernon Hills, Illinois, USA

posted 22 January 2006 04:30 AM     profile     
I have gone to two 12" speakers in closed-back cabinets on the floor pointed just a little bit up. As Brad pointed out, a speaker will beam at the high frequencies. A 15" speaker "beams" down to a lower frequency than a 12" does, so a 15" is more beamy than a 12". A lot comes into play with how a speaker disperses. For instance, an open-back cabinet will send almost as many mids and highs out of the back of the cabinet as the front. And if there is a reflective wall behind the amp, it has a big effect on the sound, especially to the side of the amp, where band mates sometimes hear you. In the end, I think you should put your speaker(s) where they sound best to you and send as little off the stage as possible. If you are honking off the stage without being in the PA, try to position them so you and the audience are in the same relative position to the speaker's beaminess. That's when two 12" can sort of straddle your body and more highs can get more places.
TC
John De Maille
Member

From: Merrick,N.Y. U.S.A.

posted 22 January 2006 07:07 AM     profile     
I used to place my amp on a chair behind me, but, found a loss in bass response. Not much, but, it bothered me. So now, I place "them" behind me on the floor. I'm not an acoustical engineer, so, I can't tell you why, but, the floor mount adds more bottom to the sound. Probably something to do with a sympathetic vibration. I don't know, it justs works better for me.
David Doggett
Member

From: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA

posted 22 January 2006 09:41 AM     profile     
A big part of why speakers sound more bassy on the floor is that the lows are much less directional than the highs. With the speaker on a stand, the directional highs are closer to ear level and sound louder, same with tilting the amp. When you put the speaker on the floor, especially with no tilt, the directional highs are not pointed directly at your ears, and the less directional bass comes through louder to you, but not necessarily to the audience out front. There may be some additional bass boost by coupling the speaker cab bottom to the floor. But you get most of this effect even when the amp is on wheels, and there is no direct contact with the floor. What would happen if you put the speaker on a concrete floor? I'll bet it would still sound bassier, but I can't imagine the concrete doing much coupling. I just don't like putting speakers on the floor, because almost half of the speaker's sound hits the floor and gets bounced to the ceiling.

Different posters above are talking about two completely different situations, miked and unmiked speakers. Even if my amp is miked, I want it to be heard evenly across the whole stage. This means getting it toward the back, raised closer to ear level, and pointing across the stage. It doesn't bother me at all if the crowd in front of the stage hears the stage volume. At least those down front hear what the musicians intend rather that what the sound man wants. But then, I don't have a lot of experience using my amp as my personal monitor. At times when I have had my amp miked, I usually position it the same as the guitar players position theirs, which is usually so that it projects to the entire stage, not just to me.

[This message was edited by David Doggett on 22 January 2006 at 12:50 PM.]

All times are Pacific (US)

next newest topic | next oldest topic

Administrative Options: Close Topic | Archive/Move | Delete Topic
Post New Topic  
Hop to:

Contact Us | The Pedal Steel Pages

Note: Messages not explicitly copyrighted are in the Public Domain.

Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.46

Our mailing address is:
The Steel Guitar Forum
148 South Cloverdale Blvd.
Cloverdale, CA 95425 USA

Support the Forum