posted 15 November 2005 10:16 PM
profile
Ultimately Ed's research will likely prove itself in musical expresssion.After the theory and physical layout are codified
in relation to theory logic and physical logic,
then some smart player will start really
making "Music" with one of these monsters.
If the organization is as correct as it appears,
then the process of making music on it
will likely be pretty quick in the right hands.
I am sure Ed picks on it, and it satisfies his logical cravings.
And I have heard nothing but good comments from others who have tried it. Other than their not understanding it to much at first.
The man, not the machine being the falling point at first.
I suspect this instrument will be best served on some new player,
with few preconcieved ideas about what it should do.
"But, can I play Mansion on The Hill like Buddy did back when,
or last month at Show X."
Well maybe not,
but you CAN play a gorgeous version of Mansion On The Hill on it.
But it's when it is working on Epistrophy, Anthropology, or Donna Lee that it's logic will prove itself more fully.
As much as it might be cool to hand one to Paul Franklin or another of like stature,
for 2 years, and then hear what he comes up with.
He likely doesn't have the time to retrain himself to the extent needed.
Plus, why add different muscle memory habits,
to confuse a solid existing working situtation.
So that leaves the talented newcomer,
or someone off the mainstsream,
with strong ideas, and nothing to loose,
when learning a semi-renagade machines logic,
and by logic throwing away most of the older schools logic.
Nothing against it, but it was then and this is now. etc.
As to low strings crossing into the bass too much,
well it's a question of Tone Eq and taste.
Just because it can get so low,
doesn't mean it needs the same tonal balance as the bassplayer uses.
Piano players still play full range lkeft hand even with a contrabass player. They DO have a differenht tone. Sure HOW they play down low is modified a bit from playing solo, but as much as you migh suspect.
I might think about having a different pickup with either different, output jack, changed windings,
or actual eq for the low 4 strings.
Similar to Brett Masons 2 part Tele pickups. He has 4 strings like a standard tele,
and the twangy top two with a different winding.
So that could work for an S-14 too, just in inverse.
[This message was edited by David L. Donald on 15 November 2005 at 10:21 PM.]