Steel Guitar Strings Strings & instruction for lap steel, Hawaiian & pedal steel guitars http://SteelGuitarShopper.com |
Ray Price Shuffles Classic country shuffle styles for Band-in-a-Box, by BIAB guru Jim Baron. http://steelguitarmusic.com |
This Forum is CLOSED. |
![]() |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
profile | join | preferences | help | search
|
This topic is 6 pages long: 1 2 3 4 5 6 This topic was originally posted in this forum: Pedal Steel |
Author | Topic: Intonation Tips / Drills Wanted |
Joey Ace Sysop Posts: 7232 |
![]() ![]() I'd like to hear what types of exersizes you do, or tips you have, to practice proper pitch. I find playing a note-for-note solo with a CD is a big help. You can hear any error when you're playing along. I also like Joe Wright's drills and exersizes. Paralex error is a factor when playing below the 5th fret or above the 15th. I've learned to adjust what I expect to see. Example: on the first fret, I expect to see the fret line to the right of the bar, at the 12th fret you do not see fret line. I suspect intonation is an on-going challenge for us. Thanks in advance for the advice! -j0e- |
rayman unregistered Posts: 7232 |
![]() Joey, the way to conquer intonation is this. Visually map out your guitar up and down the neck using your fourth string E as your root. Use a meter to determine when you are on dead o as you move the bar up the neck. It sounds like you have started to do this by ear. If you do this with a meter you will know visually just where all your frets should apear as relates to paralex and dead on intonation. The A& F position needs to be sharped due to double tempering. Its fool proof. Good luck. [This message was edited by rayman on 28 August 2001 at 07:12 AM.] |
Bobby Lee Sysop Posts: 14849 |
![]() ![]() I think that practicing to MIDI tracks (or Band-in-a-Box) helps a lot. MIDI from a computer is very much in tune to A=440, and you can change the key of the tunes at will to exercise in different positions. ------------------ |
Bob Hoffnar Member Posts: 4278 |
![]() ![]() I made quite a bit of progress when I stopped using a tuner when I practice. It forced me to rely on my ears which are the real thing that need to be worked on to improve intonation. Intonation is a function of recognition of pitch which is a function of your mind and the ability to adjust to the proper pitch which is a function of your hearing. Using a tuner or paralax formula is a function of your vision which seems sorta goofy to me. Whatever works for you is right though. Find an ear training program and spend some real time with it. I use this guy's stuff : Hearing myself on tape is a big help also (that is if I can stand it !). Bob |
Don Olson Member Posts: 139 |
![]() ![]() If you have a Piano thats in tune go through the scales with it and sing the notes as you do.You will be very surprised how mich that helps. ZUNSTEEL Forever |
Ron Castle Member Posts: 229 |
![]() ![]() This may seem like a joke, but I'm quite serious. Practice with your eyes closed, go thru scales and harmonized scales slowly. 20 minutes a day.. you'll be amazed what it will do for your ear/intonation. dont forget, if you were reading and playing fiddle you couldnt look either! |
Joey Ace Sysop Posts: 7232 |
![]() ![]() Thanks to all above. Keep them Coming! Several of the posts gave advice for developing my ears. This is indeed the most important first step, but not my original question. Having 30+ years of musical experience, and some formal, and much informal, ear training, I have that under control. Of course it's a lifelong pursuit. My real question is how to transfer this to the physical instrument. I play well, but am always seeking ways to improve. Rayman's advice, to check yourself mechanically is valid. Learning the sightlines is important. Bobby's advice to play along with a source is also important. I use a Reed Kolter TR-1000 to loop parts from CDs, tapes. Ron's "play blind" advice is also good. Joe Wright is a big influence for me. He often plays looking straight ahead. When there's a lick I must learn "perfect", I'll loop on it and play along until I can look away. So even though the above posts may seem to contradict each other, I see them as all true, and pieces to this puzzle. I'm still lookin for more. Keep them Coming! -j0e- |
C Allen Member Posts: 441 |
![]() ![]() Ron Castle, I was gonna say the same thing. Practice with you eyes CLOSED. A little story might help here. When I was playing guitar in clubs years ago, there was always some drunk in the house that thought he could sing. We always let these fools on the stage, and sometimes it was fun. But..........they rarely had any sence of timing, or pitch. Even some Pro's and semi-Pro's have bad timing and pitch. Playing with this type of person caused me to learn how to anticipate. A definate form of Ear training. Also, back then I had a bass player friend, that used to practice to broken records..........ON PURPOSE.......for the same reason. I studied violin in school, and one thing that my Uncle told me(he was a proffesor at the school) was to get mad at it, and just play it. I think the same rule applies. Just play it. |
Joey Ace Sysop Posts: 7232 |
![]() ![]() quote: I doubt I'll be able to follow a skipping CD. [This message was edited by Joey Ace on 29 August 2001 at 08:00 AM.] |
Ricky Davis Moderator Posts: 6522 |
![]() ![]() Well I can't seem to find a suggestion I had on here before; so I'll attempt to explain what I have done to improve my intonation. I have a metronome with a "A" tone that sounds out constantly if I select it as opposed to the Beats per minute. So I'll stick that thing on a music stand right in front of my steel and with the amp on and "no reverb">"no effects" whatsoever; I play anything> "a bunch or chords""single note lines""a solo I might know" or just moving up and down the neck in certain keys that work with a "A" note in it. You can play in A of course; but also F and G and D and C and E; and there is a "A" note availiable as a color tone in all those keys. This exercise has really practiced my ear for listening up and down the neck and the ever changing intonation of the steel guitar; to be in tune with that constant "A" tone; no matter what key you are in or what scale you may be playing or what solo you might choose from. Without the reverb and playing/practicing this way; you can hear the slightest inperfections in intonation; and you learn to listen and make the smallest adjustments to play with perfect intonation. The more you work at it; the quicker your ear will be to make the adjustments needed to play with perfect intonation. Remember the Fret lines or only a reference to where the proper pitch is; "your ear and how you hear proper pitch/intonation is what needs to be accurate"....so if you practice this way; your ear will become more accurate in no time at all. A single tone sounding out, does not lie and does not move; a CD or song to play along with changes constantly and will more often give you a since of intonation from alot of tones sounding out; but "will" lie to you about your intonation. Prepare and bake the cake first; then put the icing on it with playing along with music. Ricky |
Drew Grice Member Posts: 194 |
![]() ![]() I think you first have to know what you are playing. I find that my intonation and tone greatly improve when I'm dead sure of what I am going to play first. Then, as I'm comfortable with it the intonation an tone improve. |
Tom Ensink Member Posts: 101 |
![]() ![]() Important for intonation is positioning the left hand (trivial right?). So go up and down the neck. Don't exercise the scales in one position. This is a drill which I have been taught by Jeff Newman and I still do it. To practice and to warm up. It works really well for me. Play two voice major scales using the same two strings when you go up and down the neck. Do thirds (4th and 5th string, e.g. 3af, 5a, 7a, 8af, 10af, 12a, 14a, 15af and back) or fifths (3rd and 5th string, e.g. 3ab, 6, 8, 8ab, 10ab, 13, 15, 15ab etc.). Now program a biab or midi file, 4/4 moderate tempo (like e.g. Silver Wings), using one chord or two chords each bar just going up and down the scale: Up is 1, 2-, 3-, 4, 5, 6-, 5, 1. To go back use 1, 3-, 4, 3-, 4, 1, 5, 1 (or chords e.g. c, dm, em, f, g, am, g7, c and back up c, em, f, em, f, c, g, c). Now transpose the midi file in all keys, and fool around with it. If you do the exercise on strings 4 and 5, try using the a pedal and f lever, instead of the e lever. This is a nice exercise because everytime you play with these pedals/levers, you have to play a little bit behind the fret to play a correct intonation. Jeff told me a story that he was at the convention a couple of years back in a hotel room next to Buddy Emmons. Emmons was practising scales ALL NIGHT. I hope you understand the drill. Good luck. PS Greetings from the Netherlands to all of the friends I met at the convention this year. Will be back soon. Tom (The Dutch guy) ------------------ |
chas smith Member Posts: 3168 |
![]() ![]() Another thing you might do is record yourself playing along with a CD or tape and then listen back to see where you're 'pitchy', then go back and do it again. If I'm aware that I'm having a problem in a particular area, then I can be more focussed when it comes up again. There were a number of threads devoted to whether to tune in Just or ET, and I normally tune to a combination of both. I had a session recently where I had to tune the guitar straight up ET and since I was 'out in front' I had to really concentrate on the 3rd and 4th strings up around the 12th fret. If you are playing a lot of fast notes, then you can get away with a little slop, but long-tone single notes with other instruments are deadly. |
Larry Behm Member Posts: 1686 |
![]() ![]() Join a band that plays louder, then you can concentrate on what you are playing as it relates to the song and leave the intonation to fend for itself. You sound like you are more than on the right track, now get on the train and ride. Larry Behm |
Ray Montee Member Posts: 4090 |
![]() ![]() Lots of great things to think about! But being perfectly honest....some of you folks have come up with problems and ambitious, technical solutions that during the past 58 years, have never crossed my mind; and yet, I've been complimented for years for my tone quality; in-tuneness (how about that one?); and have managed to play with music teachers and life-long professional musicians as well as various Nashville recording artists without a single complaint. I started in loud dance halls, moved into live radio, live stage performances both indoors and outdoors, recording studios and yes, live television. If one gets out of tune, it is REQUIRED that you get back in tune instantly and not some time down the line when you have time to hookup all of your electronic gadgets that might tell you that you're offending others around you. Toss the gadgets out (for awhile, at least). Turn off all of the affects and learn to play JUST THE GUITAR! Teach your ear to HEAR.....and then practice tuning your guitar by FEEL, just a little sharper; just a little flatter; or whatever. If you can't tune accurately, how in the world can you expect to play music? Beautiful music is an EAR thing. If you have no ear, you have only a room full of gadgets. Right? or Wrong? Jerry Byrd mentioned to me just the other day, that "learning to tune" his old Bakelite Rick during the early days of TV and all.....was a real task. However, due to the heat of lights and cold of air conditioning, it was a NECESSITY. If your ear is under-developed for the accuracy of sound.....you'll likely never be able to tell if your out of tune; let alone, being able to make that subtle knob twisting movement to bring it back in tune BEFORE your next chance at the spotlight.....all the while the entire band is playing their respective hotlicks and all. |
This topic is 6 pages long: 1 2 3 4 5 6 All times are Pacific (US) | This is an ARCHIVED topic. You may not reply to it! |
Note: Messages not explicitly copyrighted are in the Public Domain.
Our mailing address is:
The Steel Guitar Forum
148 South Cloverdale Blvd.
Cloverdale, CA 95425 USA
Support the Forum