Author
|
Topic: Looking For Feedback... New Tab Program!
|
Doug Beaumier Member From: Northampton, MA
|
posted 10 August 2001 06:40 PM
profile
I've been working with the folks at TablEdit to come up with a workable program for 10 string E9 tablature with notation. Below is a sample of what TablEdit has come up with so far. I think it looks pretty good! I want your opinions/ feedback. Matthieu Leschemelle at TablEdit is working very hard to accommodate we picky pedal steel pickers! He wants to hear from you. The sample below is the first line of Beyond The Reef from my new 16 EASY SONGS package Shameless Plug!. What you see is TableEdit's version of my arrangement. I sent Matt a copy and he put this together. (There is a tie missing on the A note at the end of measure 4 to the A note at the beginning of measure 5). Matthieu tells me that the numbers and letters could be placed in the lines instead of on the spaces. I think that's a good idea, since that's what we are all used to. In addition, there is audio in the program, so you can hear what you just entered. I did not link the audio file to this post. If you have any ideas or opinions please email Matthieu Leschemelle at matthieu@tabledit.com and post your ideas here. He's looking for input from us. Thanks! ------------------ www.dougbsteel.com
[This message was edited by Doug Beaumier on 10 August 2001 at 06:42 PM.]
|
Joe Delaronde Member From: Selkirk, Manitoba, Canada
|
posted 10 August 2001 06:58 PM
profile
Doug Correct me if I'm wrong or mixed up. Will it make tab if you enter the notes or will it make notes if you enter the tab or will it do both? Will various tunings & different copedents be be possible? Thanks Joe |
Pat Burns Member From: Branchville, N.J. USA
|
posted 10 August 2001 07:00 PM
profile
..just at a glance I find that the notation makes the tab much easier to hear in my head...I've read notation since I was a kid, and especially for voice I can quickly look and hear in my head where the music is going...that's always been the shortcoming of tab for me, I can't "visualize", or hear in my head, where the music is going with tab...this makes it clear to me where the tab is going......aside from the intervals, it makes the timing clear...tab doesn't do that at all... ...how about including the lyrics under the notation if there are vocals, that would put the icing on the cake..you wouldn't even need an instrument, you could just play it in your head... ...I like it a lot...
[This message was edited by Pat Burns on 10 August 2001 at 07:33 PM.]
|
b0b Sysop From: Cloverdale, California, USA
|
posted 10 August 2001 07:06 PM
profile
It looks very professional. It would work better on the Forum if it wasn't quite so wide, though. We have to allow for the Author column on the left side, and for the fact that some people are still using 640x480 screens.------------------
-b0b- quasar@b0b.com -System Administrator
|
Roy Thomson Member From: Wolfville, Nova Scotia,Canada
|
posted 10 August 2001 07:07 PM
profile
That's nice Doug. Very clean! I have also had email communication with Matthieu. One suggestion I stressed was to compress the Notation with the tab close enough so that it would be possible to get at least 4 lines of each when printing to 8 X 11 stationary. Another suggestion I gave him was to use #'s and "b's" both single and double instead of letters for pedals/knee levers. This is more universal and would apply to any tuning etc. (b0b's idea which I think has a lot of merit.) I still look forward to the day when we can disperse with the tab and just incorporate the music staff with notations/hinting for the frets and pedal changes. I have referred Matthieu to my work in this regard on the ClicTab site to see some of my possible approaches. It can be done but I cannot write the software for it. Someone should. I have also communicated with Ron Turner and apprised him of my communication with Matthieu. He is aware of what is happening. I beleive something good will come of it all and I am so pleased that you are on the bandwagon..the perfect man for the job. I have a feeling that in collaboration with Matthieu you will come up with something really nice. I look forward to the outcome. Roy |
Doug Beaumier Member From: Northampton, MA
|
posted 10 August 2001 07:43 PM
profile
Thanks Roy, Matt is looking for other "collaborators" too. One thing about the steel community... there is no shortage of opinions!Joe, On the standard TablEdit guitar program, you may enter the tab and the note will appear at the same moment or you may enter the note and the tab will appear. But it may not appear on the sting or fret you want it to, and then you can simply change that. I don't know how Matt has set this up... considering the pedal steel's multiple locations for any 1 note. You'd have to ask him through an email, since he is the one who actually put this sample together. You can download a DEMO of the current tabledit HERE. The current version allows you to expand to 10 strings and use any tuning you want. Try experimenting with the editing and entering, etc. The new pedal steel version should work in a similar fashion. bob, sorry about the wide gif file. I just posted what was sent to me. Is there any way to reduce such a file before submitting it to the forum? ------------------ www.dougbsteel.com
[This message was edited by Doug Beaumier on 12 August 2001 at 08:30 AM.]
|
Gord Cole Member From: Toronto, Ontario, Canada
|
posted 11 August 2001 05:49 AM
profile
My thought for what it's worth. I think you may find it a little easier to read the pedal tab if the line was not included between the fret number and the pedal letter.Example: THIS-––3A---- NOT THIS---3-A---- Regards. Gord |
Joe Delaronde Member From: Selkirk, Manitoba, Canada
|
posted 11 August 2001 08:33 AM
profile
Thanks Doug. It seems to be a simplified way for tabbing. And that's for me. This old simple Canadian boy needs things simpler the better. It's a matter of grey matter, you know! Joe |
Steve Feldman Member From: Millbury, MA USA
|
posted 11 August 2001 08:38 AM
profile
Beautiful! |
CHIP FOSSA Member From: Monson, MA 01057 U.S.A.
|
posted 11 August 2001 06:51 PM
profile
Doug, I posted a reply in Pedal Steel. Check it out, if you want. Are you using the full Tabledit program? |
Doug Beaumier Member From: Northampton, MA
|
posted 11 August 2001 07:16 PM
profile
Chip,I've got the demo right now, but I'm going to get the full version as soon as the PSG tab feature is straightened out. Here is the latest sample... numbers and letters in the spaces, and chord names: If you have any ideas or opinions please email Matthieu Leschemelle at matthieu@tabledit.com and post your ideas here. ------------------ www.dougbsteel.com
[This message was edited by Doug Beaumier on 11 August 2001 at 07:20 PM.]
|
Jim Cohen Member From: Philadelphia, PA
|
posted 11 August 2001 08:05 PM
profile
Hmmm... I thought that most players preferred having the numbers/letter ON the lines rather than in the spaces, no? Did I imagine that? (Although one should discontinue printing the line at the point where the number/letter is written, so they don't overlap) |
Joe Delaronde Member From: Selkirk, Manitoba, Canada
|
posted 11 August 2001 08:38 PM
profile
Just registered and waiting for the code #. Looks great!!!! Joe |
Bosse Engzell Member From: Äppelbo, SWEDEN
|
posted 11 August 2001 08:54 PM
profile
Looks very good. Will it work with MIDI also?? What is the cost for this software mail me that please.Bosse in Sweden |
Doug Beaumier Member From: Northampton, MA
|
posted 11 August 2001 09:48 PM
profile
Jim, I had the line/space thing back @ssward in my original post so I corrected it. The numbers in the space is what we're all used to, but TablEdit has always put the numbers on the lines (for standard guitar). This pedal steel program is a work in progress. If you have questions email Matthieu Leschemelle at matthieu@tabledit.com ------------------ www.dougbsteel.com
|
CHIP FOSSA Member From: Monson, MA 01057 U.S.A.
|
posted 11 August 2001 10:26 PM
profile
Yeah Jim! C'mon. Whaddaya want??? Huh??? |
MUSICO Member From: Jeremy Williams in Spain
|
posted 12 August 2001 06:09 AM
profile
Yes, it works with MIDI as wellI am a registered user because of its fantastic archive of free acoustic guitar tabs. When I want a new piece to learn I sit down and listen to it play a few dozen pieces til one takes my fancy. It plays slaps, pops, harmonics bends damped notes strums....plays a lot better than most acoustic guitarista in my opinion. Rick and Rebel's Tab archive should be passed across to Tabledit format as soon as Tabledit has the PSG solved. Jeremy Williams Gandia Valencia Spain |
Roy Thomson Member From: Wolfville, Nova Scotia,Canada
|
posted 12 August 2001 08:29 AM
profile
I have emailed Matthieu and asked if the Demo and/or registered version allows for music notation/tablature to be converted to a .bmp file. This would make it possible to use other programs ie Windows Paint for additional editing. I have done this extensively with ClicTab. I mention it here as this feature may be of interest to others also. It makes it possible to personalize you work if you so desire. Roy T.[This message was edited by Roy Thomson on 12 August 2001 at 08:30 AM.] |
Steve Feldman Member From: Millbury, MA USA
|
posted 12 August 2001 10:34 AM
profile
Doug (or anyone) -I'm fooling around with the program right now, and it's defaulted to putting the notes (numerical) on the lines, but the pitch changes (e.g., pedal letters) on the spaces below the corresponding line. How do you fix that, or alternatively go back and forth between line mode and space mode? |
Roy Thomson Member From: Wolfville, Nova Scotia,Canada
|
posted 12 August 2001 11:31 AM
profile
I have received a reply from Matthieu in respect to my post above. He informs me that you came create a .bmp file of your music/tab in both the Demo and the Registered version by clicking the export button in Print Preview. He also sent me a sample of tab he made using the... #'s... and ...b's... rather than letters for the pedals. This will be an optional feature I assume along with numbers on the lines or spaces. |
MUSICO Member From: Jeremy Williams in Spain
|
posted 12 August 2001 02:25 PM
profile
What can I say to get everyone to try this program out??The author is CONSTANTLY improving it....and by that I mean adding things that users suggest...it does harmonica tab!!!!! Dulcimer tab!!!!! Lyrics chords....you name it he programs it. How about this for an offer to the members who double on 6 string....if anyone's interested, download the program and email me...I'll send you some Django Reinhardt or CHet Atkins note for note transcriptions. Jeremy Williams Gandia Valencia Spain |
Doug Beaumier Member From: Northampton, MA
|
posted 12 August 2001 02:47 PM
profile
Steve,You need to reset the tab options so that the number will appear in the space. Try this: Click on FILE Click on OPTIONS the "General" file should be showing look on the right side and where is says "Tablature Presentation" click on the right circle and then click on OK This will put your tab numbers in the space. There will still be 10 lines (not 11 lines like in most of our 10 string tab). String 1 numbers should be entered above the top line. The open string "note names" will continue to align with the lines, not the spaces. That is one thing that will hopefully be corrected soon. The programmer works every day on TablEdit to make improvements. Registered users can always get the latest version. ------------------ www.dougbsteel.com
[This message was edited by Doug Beaumier on 12 August 2001 at 02:50 PM.] [This message was edited by Doug Beaumier on 12 August 2001 at 03:54 PM.]
|
Matthieu Leschemelle Member From: Suresnes, France
|
posted 13 August 2001 12:58 AM
profile
Hello Folks,I'm replying to your last postings, I'd like to tell you I never got such a feedback from any musical community. It's really nice :-) I'm refering to the latest TablEdit update (v2.60). I've uploaded a demo version http://www.tabledit.com/download/tev260d.exe (280 KB) in order you can test the program without having to register (to pay for the complete version) right now. My replies are in caps. Hmmm... I thought that most players preferred having the numbers/letter ON the lines rather than in the spaces, no? Did I imagine that? (Although one should discontinue printing the line at the point where the number/letter is written, so they don't overlap) NO PROBLEM.THERE IS AN OPTION. YOU CAN STILL USE THE OLD GOOD SYSTEM OF TABLEDIT. BUT IF YOU CHECK THE "PEDAL STEEL GUITAR" OPTION OF THE INSTRUMENT DIALOG BOX, THE TABLATURE WILL BE DISPLAYED WITH THE NUMBER IN THE SPACES. Looks very good. Will it work with MIDI also?? YES THE PITCH CHANGES CHANGE THE NOTE TO BE PLAYED PROPERLY. IF THE "PEDAL STEEL GUITAR" OPTION OF THE INSTRUMENT DIALOG BOX IS CHECKED, THERE IS ALSO A SLIGHT PITCH BEND EFFECT TO SIMULATE THE PEDAL OR LEVER ACTION. What is the cost for this software mail me that please. TABLEDIT COSTS 55 $US. THE UPDATES ARE COMPLETELY FREE FOR REGISTERED USERS. Rick and Rebel's Tab archive should be passed across to Tabledit format as soon as Tabledit has the PSG solved. HONESTLY, I THINK THE SOLVING IS VERY CLOSE. IN http://www.tabledit.com/download/psg01.zip, YOU'LL FIND SOME IMAGES TO SHOW THE VARIOUS POSSIBILITIES YOU ALREADY CAN GET WITH V2.60. I have emailed Matthieu and asked if the Demo and/or registered version allows for music notation/tablature to be converted to a .bmp file. This would make it possible to use other programs ie Windows Paint for additional editing. I have done this extensively with ClicTab. I mention it here as this feature may be of interest to others also. It makes it possible to personalize you work if you so desire. AS I'VE ALREADY EXPLAINED, MY PRINCIPLE AS SOFTWARE DEVELOPER IS TO OFFER ALL THE NECESSARY FLEXIBILITY TO THE FINAL USER. SO YOU SHOULD BE ABLE TO GET ANY RESULT THAT COULD BE REASONABLY EXPECTED AND IT SHOULD NOT BE NECESSARY TO EDIT TEDIOUSLY AN IMAGE WITH A GRAPHIC EDITOR. I'm fooling around with the program right now, and it's defaulted to putting the notes (numerical) on the lines, but the pitch changes (e.g., pedal letters) on the spaces below the corresponding line. How do you fix that, or alternatively go back and forth between line mode and space mode? SINCE YOU ARE USING THE VERSION 2.50, YOU CAN'T TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THE NEW FEATURES OF V2.60. PLEASE DOWNLOAD THE VERSION 2.60 DEMO FROM THE LINK ABOVE. |
Matthieu Leschemelle Member From: Suresnes, France
|
posted 13 August 2001 01:04 AM
profile
Regarding the tuning note alignment, it is fixed in v2.60.You don't need to play with the Tablature Presentation options. Just check the "Pedal Steel Guitar" option in {Score | Instrument} dialog.
|
CHIP FOSSA Member From: Monson, MA 01057 U.S.A.
|
posted 13 August 2001 05:22 AM
profile
Matt, I have downloaded the registered v2.60 version and went looking for "pedal steel guitar" in SCORE/INSTRUMENTS as you mentioned but cannot find it. Has this feature just been added? I downloaded v2.60 about 2 weeks ago. Maybe I should download v2.60 again? Thanks, CF.[This message was edited by CHIP FOSSA on 13 August 2001 at 05:23 AM.] |
Matthieu Leschemelle Member From: Suresnes, France
|
posted 13 August 2001 05:41 AM
profile
Yes Chip, you have to download the latest v2.60 (the one I've uploaded yesterday).I'm currently working on PSG support in a very unusual but efficient interactive process: I note the suggestions of the Steel Guitar Forum's members, I make the changes in the program, then I wait for the remarks and suggestions, and so on... So there are changes everyday ;-) |
MUSICO Member From: Jeremy Williams in Spain
|
posted 13 August 2001 08:38 AM
profile
Ok Heres another suggestion.....for me and a lot of other players......12 strings are needed...the absolute maximum is 14 if Im not mistaken.Jeremy Williams Gandia Valencia Spain Registered user
|
Matthieu Leschemelle Member From: Suresnes, France
|
posted 13 August 2001 02:06 PM
profile
TablEdit supports up to 12 strings that you can tune as you want. |
Marco Schouten Member From: Amsterdam, The Netherlands
|
posted 13 August 2001 03:26 PM
profile
Can the program do the following: a tab on E9th tuning, change the tuning to C6 and you get the new tab for that song for C6???? Or if I have a E9th tab but want to play on a U12, can the program handle it by itsself?------------------ Steelin' Greetings Marco Schouten Sho-Bud Pro III Custom |
Matthieu Leschemelle Member From: Suresnes, France
|
posted 13 August 2001 03:55 PM
profile
TablEdit is actually able to convert the tablature from one tuning to a new one.I don't promise you will get the best fingerings. But at least, you won't loose any note ;-)
|
Doug Beaumier Member From: Northampton, MA
|
posted 13 August 2001 08:09 PM
profile
Here is a QUICK GUIDE to getting started with the new TablEdit. (I'll post better instructions when I get more time): open the program and: 1) click on SCORE at the top 2) in the dropdown menu click on INSTRUMENT 3) then click on the PEDAL STEEL GUITAR option and click on OK 4) using the arrows on your keyboard, put the blue square on a desired string (space) and enter a number 5) to add letters for pedals and levers, click on NOTE up above, and in the dropdown menu click on PITCH CHANGE. Choose a letter, for example... A , and that letter should appear right after the number in your tablature. You may also plus or minus the pitch in that box. I think that will affect the MIDI audio pitch. I'm still learning about this myself.By the way, this program may be used for dobro, lap steel, guitar or any other instrument with up to 12 strings. It has so many features... it's beyond belief! ------------------ www.dougbsteel.com
[This message was edited by Doug Beaumier on 13 August 2001 at 08:11 PM.]
|
MUSICO Member From: Jeremy Williams in Spain
|
posted 14 August 2001 03:53 AM
profile
Matthieu, carefull with that "tuning change option" you mention. I use it a lot on 6 string guitar, and as you say, it gives you "a" fingering option, maybe not the best but then you can change a note from string to string.I am amazed at how quickly I can import a midi and have a workable guitar arrangement. It is a truly fantastic option for guitar. Pedal steel is different. As its played with a bar your standard fingering algorithms wont work. You cant simultaneously play notes on different strings at different fret positions. The way of arranging is finding the position where all the notes are aligned. Pedals are used to raise and lower string pitch so that all the desired notes align at a certain fret for a moment. Jeremy Williams Gandia Valencia Spain |
MUSICO Member From: Jeremy Williams in Spain
|
posted 14 August 2001 04:06 AM
profile
I hope I explained it well.....cos I warn all you guys, Matthieu is capable of almost anything to make this program perfect for PSG users. He's done it for other instruments and continues to support them as long as feedback keeps coming in.Let's get downloading and registering...as with other communities he wont stop til he gets it perfect. But he needs to be sent examples, tabs in TABLEDIT format with an explanation of what it does, and if its wrong, what it should do and why, This is too good an opportunity for the PSG community to pass up. Imagine a standard format for passing around PSG tabs....but a format that will permit you to have in one file the tab, and a way of hearing the music, slowing down to any speed for practice play along. This program can also have the accompaniment....you can put in guitar tab, bass tab, drum track, a chord accompaniment track (you can import the midi file produced by band in the box....then we wouldnt need to buy band in a box to reproduce back up tracks. It will print out lead sheets just like jeff newman uses with the chords | E E | B7 | A | A E ! Im gushing so much that perhaps I should state that I have no connection with Tabledit other than the one you all will have soon....a 110% satisfied customer Jeremy Williams Gandia Valencia Spain |
CHIP FOSSA Member From: Monson, MA 01057 U.S.A.
|
posted 14 August 2001 05:13 AM
profile
Jeremy, I hate to blab this again, but I've been ranting about Tabledit for almost 3 years here on the Forum, and only as of lately, has any large interest been shown. I think when Matt finally dropped in and introduced himself and Tabledit, did interest climb.I couldn't agree more........it's a fantastic program.......I'm still finding out new things to do with Tabledit. I've bought programs that cost twice as much, and delivered twice as little. The small fee for the registered version is money well spent. And newer versions are always free; not like BIAB, for instance.[This message was edited by CHIP FOSSA on 14 August 2001 at 05:13 AM.] |
MUSICO Member From: Jeremy Williams in Spain
|
posted 14 August 2001 09:46 AM
profile
Chip, It seems these things take time. I'm glad that finally it looks like we might start supporting Tabledit as a community and then Im sure tabs that play themselves and accompany themselves will start flying around the net from PSG player to PSG player. I feel the same enthusiasm for getting together in one of the audio chats, I am regularly on PALTALK in a room where acoustic guitarists play by turns and people listen comment and sometimes ask what chord/inversion or whatever was being used. Its unbeleivable how fast you can grasp musical concepts when they are played as well as explained. Jeremy Williams Gandia Valencia Spain (This weekend Billy Phelps in Barcelona) |
CHIP FOSSA Member From: Monson, MA 01057 U.S.A.
|
posted 14 August 2001 07:18 PM
profile
Jeremy....I'd be interested in your acoustic chat room.......please email at:seatug@mediaone.net............and we'll take it from here. Thanks. Chip |
Johan Jansen Member From: Europe
|
posted 15 August 2001 07:11 AM
profile
Hi Mathieu, is it possible to learn the program some "pockets", related to scales, runs, usual pedalchanges,etc. both on E9 andC6, so the tab knows how a player thinks, when translating from midi to tab? Thanks, JJ------------------ STEELDAYS 2002 my web-site my bands CODand TSC
|
Matthieu Leschemelle Member From: Suresnes, France
|
posted 15 August 2001 07:36 AM
profile
Johan,Everything is possible. I just need to know the rules to be applied (and to be convinced it is useful to implement them ;-). Matthieu
|
MUSICO Member From: Jeremy Williams in Spain
|
posted 15 August 2001 11:53 AM
profile
Useful???The Pedal Steel Guitar community would give their right arm for a program with that capacity (it wouldn't do any harm...we play with our knees and feet) :-) But seriously....we would need to put a LOT of effort into explaining a logical way to calculate where to play an arrangement. Matthieu could program it...but Im not sure we could describe it to him. May I suggest that each PSG form member who registers the program inform Mathieu that they are registering for use as a PSG tab software so he knows that we are backing his efforts. He is still adding acoustic guitar capacity to the program ...long after it became better than the best in the market...we are paying a one time price for a person who is willing to continually support all our software needs now and in the future. Jeremy Williams Gandia Valencia Spain |
Joe Delaronde Member From: Selkirk, Manitoba, Canada
|
posted 15 August 2001 01:52 PM
profile
It's just simply fan-"TAB"-ulous. Couldn't resist. Joe |