Steel Guitar Strings Strings & instruction for lap steel, Hawaiian & pedal steel guitars http://SteelGuitarShopper.com |
Ray Price Shuffles Classic country shuffle styles for Band-in-a-Box, by BIAB guru Jim Baron. http://steelguitarmusic.com |
This Forum is CLOSED. |
![]() |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
profile | join | preferences | help | search
|
This topic is 7 pages long: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 This topic was originally posted in this forum: Pedal Steel |
Author | Topic: A bent string, is a spent string. |
Lee Baucum Member Posts: 3201 |
![]() ![]() Bill - Since installing the "Lucky 7" on your guitar, have you noticed any decrease in volume or sustain of that particular string. I would think that if you decrease the angle at which the string crosses over the changer finger, there would be less downward pressure, thereby reducing the volume and sustain. ------------------ |
Tommy Mc Member Posts: 190 |
![]() ![]() In a perfect world, the 'ideal' string would never break, and never lose it's tone. Perhaps strings that don't break (or guitars that don't break them) are a first step in that direction. Now my dilemma... I am changing my strings for the big New Year's gig. All the strings are old and flat, except the 3rd, which is never more than a few gigs old. So should I change it too?.......oh never mind! |
Bill Hankey Member Posts: 1680 |
![]() ![]() Tommy Mc., Its nice to hear that you'll be |
Bill Hankey Member Posts: 1680 |
![]() ![]() Lee B. I look back on the Leo Fender days, when the designers put so much Bill H. [This message was edited by Bill Hankey on 30 December 2001 at 07:52 AM.] [This message was edited by Bill Hankey on 05 January 2002 at 02:04 AM.] |
Chris Schlotzhauer Member Posts: 1217 |
![]() ![]() Still waiting Bill |
Bill Hankey Member Posts: 1680 |
![]() ![]() Chris S. I'm still working on the "Lucky 7 concept). What I have designed already, is working fine. I want The Fender 1000 was very popular back in the 50's and 60's. The bridge design on that instrument Bill H. |
Steve Feldman Member Posts: 2983 |
![]() ![]() quote: I'm inclined to agree, Bill. We're not likely to see 300 without them... |
Jeff Lampert Member Posts: 2636 |
![]() ![]() Happy New Year to Lucky 7. |
Jeff Lampert Member Posts: 2636 |
![]() ![]() Happy New Year to GOLO. |
Jeff Lampert Member Posts: 2636 |
![]() ![]() And Happy New Year to Bill H. and everyone else. We'll get to 300, even if it takes to Jan 1, 2002. |
Jeff Lampert Member Posts: 2636 |
![]() ![]() Oops. 3003. |
Jeff Lampert Member Posts: 2636 |
![]() ![]() Oops. 2003. |
Bill Hankey Member Posts: 1680 |
![]() ![]() For a while I felt like a sparrow under a clump of twisted vines, waiting for the hawk to fly out of town. When I presented good solid evidence that would sustain "The Bent String Theory", not one reply has been made defending the bridge arrangement, on the Fender 1000's double eight, pedal steel guitar. Am I to believe that the flaws in the design were never noticed? The Fender 1000 was my bread and butter for years, until I built the steel that I use today. I should have named it the " Melody Finder", as important changes are in easy reach. Much satisfaction can be derived from building a steel guitar, and working out all of the problems, one by one, as every effort is made to correct oversight and miscalculations. Getting the exclusive changer adjustments to work properly, required a period of two years, and it is my belief that their accuracy is unequalled today. The concept just clicked into place after a two year struggle. Bill H. [This message was edited by Bill Hankey on 05 January 2002 at 03:10 AM.] |
Bill Hankey Member Posts: 1680 |
![]() ![]() Jeff L. Happy New Year to you, and to all of the members on this forum. The |
Earnest Bovine Member Posts: 4687 |
![]() ![]() On my C6/F9 universal, I pulled the high A string up to B flat. |
Bill Hankey Member Posts: 1680 |
![]() ![]() Earnest B. Would you list your tuning, from the 1st string through the 6th? If Bill H. |
Jim Smith Member Posts: 6399 |
![]() ![]() Earnest, I'd also like to know what guitar, gauge string, and scale length you're using that will allow pulling a high A-Bb. When we built Red Rhodes a Dekley for his diatonic tuning with a high Bb, he told us (and was correct) that it would have to be a 23" scale. No string we tried would tune up to a high Bb without breaking until we tried the 23" scale. ------------------ |
Paul Graupp Member Posts: 3199 |
![]() ![]() These last posts reminded me of a summer I spent at Tom Morrell's place in Dallas. He had a steel in there with a high Bb string in the front. I don't know any other particulars about the guitar but I played with it for a week or two. I have a first string A on my Carter but it would never go to a Bb. Scares me just pulling it up to a constant A (ie: no pedal changes). It's a .010 and has never broken in that position. An .011R lasts three or four weekends and then pops. Man, I hate that !! Takes an hour to pull a new one back up to pitch. ![]() ![]() Regards, Paul |
Jody Carver Member Posts: 7455 |
![]() ![]() Paul Its simple,,,,some people have more pull than others....Let me tell you about the time Oh never mind....takes too long ![]() ![]() string... ![]() star of "long stories". I surrender dear..no not me,,,,,thats an old Sinatra tune.... ![]() ![]() Ask Paul,,,he remembers all the old tunes...dontcha Paul????? |
Earnest Bovine Member Posts: 4687 |
![]() ![]() I forgot the size that high A string. |
Bobby Lee Sysop Posts: 14849 |
![]() ![]() I believe that Julian Tharpe also pulled a high A to Bb. |
Bill Hankey Member Posts: 1680 |
![]() ![]() I believe that the D9th chromatic tuning is superior in every way, in comparison with the E9th's most prominent 3rd string, string of breakages. Why then, do so many conform to E9th's string snapping pitch, and refuse to take the hint when their knuckles bleed? It is a grim reminder to make changes, if one's inclination is to do nothing. Not one player would venture to write, or proclaim,that the E9th tuning is primarily the acceptable Nashville tuning. The music would be equally enjoyable, should it be played on a D9th tuning. There is a practicality issue looming in connection with this mythical belief, that the E9th tuning, is the ultimate tuning. There are many aspects of the E9th setup that need to be discussed, to weigh each of its advantages, or hindrances. Bill H. [This message was edited by Bill Hankey on 10 January 2002 at 03:01 PM.] [This message was edited by Bill Hankey on 12 January 2002 at 03:30 AM.] |
Paul Graupp Member Posts: 3199 |
![]() ![]() It strikes me that in reading the Forum over the last few months, there have been discussions on every key ( Tuning ) except C#, F# and G#. If you want to consider the old steel tuning in C# and F# minor, that leaves only G#. Each has it's own proponents and characteristics, colors, tones, nuances or whatever one may call them. When used in a skillful manner, it is hard to tell what a players open key is. Much has been said about finding C on the first fret in one tuning or E at the second fret in another. It's like the circle of fifths and goes back where it began everytime and to what end ?? The quality of a key is in the ears of the listener and this has been so since classical times in the beginning when compositions were said to be better in this or that key for the same reasons. I think Jerry Byrd said somewhere that the open tuning of E (minor ??)on standard guitars and basses is what pushes towards the key of E or at least the use of a standard E note in any tuning on steel guitars. I feel the concentration on the breakage of just the 3rd string is kind of myopic. Other strings on steel guitars break at times as they do on other instruments including our bass player who always seems to break his A string. I don't know if he is having sympathy pains for me or what but there it is. Perhaps it's the A note that is the culprit and not the E....... Regards, Paul [This message was edited by Paul Graupp on 10 January 2002 at 07:13 AM.] |
Gene Jones Member Posts: 5796 |
![]() ![]() .... ![]() |
Bill Hankey Member Posts: 1680 |
![]() ![]() While reading through the post by Frank Parish, entitled: " Tuning To D9th", I felt the urge to respond in kind to his thread. It should be a matter of concern, when those whom have had no experience, using the D9th, or a small dabbling, in the name of curiosity, come forward and suggest string gauges to those who wish to try the D9th tuning as a solution for the first time. I submit these gauges, that will withstand a vigorous workout, under the most stressful conditions. By all means, don't go tiptoeing around, trying to move to larger gauges. This can lead to discomfort in "pedal feel". I would suggest the following gauges to start: 1st. through 10th strings: 1. .013 Bill H. [This message was edited by Bill Hankey on 11 January 2002 at 10:11 PM.] [This message was edited by Bill Hankey on 12 January 2002 at 02:47 AM.] [This message was edited by Bill Hankey on 12 January 2002 at 02:52 AM.] |
Brian Wetzstein Member Posts: 134 |
![]() ![]() Hello everyone. others have mentioned that oxidation and eventual deterioration of the string is a key factor in breakage. The oxidation seems to slow on my six string guitars if I store them in the case when not in use. Do any of you think that keeping a cover on your steel would reduce the speed of string oxidation and ultimately string breakage? I'm shooting for 300! |
Steve Feldman Member Posts: 2983 |
![]() ![]() I don't know. With 3 PSGs sitting around here, if I thought that oxidation was a big factor, I'd be tempted to get a FoodSaver and vacuum-pack one of them suckers.... |
Bill Hankey Member Posts: 1680 |
![]() ![]() Brian W., I wrote some time ago that oxygen |
Steve Feldman Member Posts: 2983 |
![]() ![]() Hoo-Whee-Boy... 188. |
Earnest Bovine Member Posts: 4687 |
![]() ![]() My strings bend more on the left than on the right. |
Bob Farlow Member Posts: 895 |
![]() ![]() I just gotta get my $.02 worth in here. I've read all the previous posts with great interest, and here are my observations and conclusions: Strings don't break because of oxidation. The strings on my MSA D10 always oxidize most in the area where the hands touch the strings. If that were the case, then they should break in that area. They never do! As Bill Hankey has correctly and very elequently stated, the culprit is the constant bending of the metal at the changer fingers.At this point the metal is being work-hardened which changes the molecular structure of the string material from a random pattern to a pattern which tends to align the molecules in a straight line. This is what causes "brittleness". Once this condition is reached, you better "watch out". The end is near! The solution is - stretch it, don't flex(bend) it. |
Bobby Lee Sysop Posts: 14849 |
![]() ![]() I've had my Williams for a year now, and have yet to break a string on it. I broke one string on my Sierra last year, but it had gone dead weeks before it broke and should have been changed anyway. When a dead string breaks, is that really a problem? We should change our strings when they go dead, not look for ways to keep them from breaking! ------------------ |
Bill Hankey Member Posts: 1680 |
![]() ![]() Bobby Lee, I don't recall advocating that a Bill H. |
Don Townsend Member Posts: 321 |
![]() ![]() Bill; Since Bobby Lee mentioned his Williams guitar, I encourage you to inspect the Series 400 Stress-Less changer Bill Rudolph has on these guitars, if you have not done so already. Your "Lucky 7" may be a retro-fit that attempts to accomplish what the Williams 400 series changer already does (if I envision your design correctly,and if I am properly interpreting your desgn objectives). |
Sage Member Posts: 525 |
![]() ![]() The Williams design holds the string straighter, and may also use a larger dia. radius at the top which would lessen work hardening of the string. Especially combined with his keyless changer, these Willams keep strings on really well. And, Bill Rudolph is one heck of a good guy. |
Sage Member Posts: 525 |
![]() ![]() Also, IMHO it is the extra snap of energy from picking so close to the radius of the changer finger that adds to the demise of strings at that point. The alternative? M o v e - t h e - c h a n g e r - t o - t h e - n u t - e n d - o f - t h e - i n s t r u m e n t . |
Steve Frost Member Posts: 262 |
![]() ![]() Sorry Sage, that's clearly not possible. That would create a systemic conflict with the Golo, which has "dibs" on the keyhead end of the steel. Bill- I tried to cajole the info out of you about 150 posts ago, but perhaps my method of inquiry was too oblique. What in Sam Hill is a Golo??!! ![]() |
Bill Hankey Member Posts: 1680 |
![]() ![]() Steve F. The "Golo" is a spring loaded device, that pulls the string down Bill H. |
Sage Member Posts: 525 |
![]() ![]() Bill, I really don't think that the string cares whether it is being stretched from one end or the other, or both. And in my nbumble opinion it is better to minimize the variables and moving parts in any system if you want it to work. Besides, a few of the guys who played console steel did retrofit their fixed string steels with pedals by drilling a hole thru the body by the tuners, running a coathanger thru it and hooking it on the string. You can do raises that way, but I don't see too many folks making them like that now. |
Bill Hankey Member Posts: 1680 |
![]() ![]() Sage, You said they could do raises with Bill H.
[This message was edited by Bill Hankey on 23 January 2002 at 03:58 AM.] |
This topic is 7 pages long: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 All times are Pacific (US) | This is an ARCHIVED topic. You may not reply to it! |
Note: Messages not explicitly copyrighted are in the Public Domain.
Our mailing address is:
The Steel Guitar Forum
148 South Cloverdale Blvd.
Cloverdale, CA 95425 USA
Support the Forum